Did you sign the petition for Pink Floyd to reunite?

  • Thread starter Thread starter brewnog
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    watch
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion centers around the recent Live 8 concert and its implications for poverty alleviation, particularly in relation to celebrity involvement and the effectiveness of such events. Participants express varying opinions on the merits of the concert, the motivations of the artists, and the overall impact on societal issues.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants enjoyed the performances, particularly highlighting Pink Floyd's reunion as a standout moment.
  • Others express skepticism about the effectiveness of celebrity-led initiatives, questioning the sincerity of wealthy individuals advocating for poverty solutions.
  • Concerns were raised regarding the allocation of funds from previous charity events, suggesting that a significant portion may not reach those in need.
  • Some argue that Live 8's purpose was not solely fundraising but aimed at pressuring G8 leaders to take action on poverty issues.
  • Participants noted differing opinions on the quality of performances, with some praising acts like The Who while criticizing Pink Floyd's performance.
  • There were references to the perceived disparity in concert lineups across different countries, with some feeling that Canada had a strong representation.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally disagree on the effectiveness and motivations behind celebrity involvement in poverty alleviation efforts. While some believe the concerts are beneficial, others remain skeptical about their impact and the intentions of the artists involved.

Contextual Notes

Some statements reflect personal opinions and experiences with the concerts, and there is a lack of consensus on the overall effectiveness of such events in addressing poverty.

brewnog
Science Advisor
Gold Member
Messages
2,751
Reaction score
8
So, who watched any of it?

I was vaguely enjoying most of the London afternoon, Sir Elton was rather entertaining, and The Who and Coldplay were pretty good too, and a surprise appearance from Richard Ashcroft, who'da thunk it? I caught a bit of Faithless in Berlin, but sadly the Germans didn't seem to get it (no, just put one finger in the air, and shout "one", ok? no? oh, sod it!). I'm wondering what the US are going to make of the Kaiser Chiefs...

But for me, the highlight was Pink Floyd's astounding reunion, how good was that?!


So, who's signed the petition?[/size]
 
Science news on Phys.org
Oh man... I don't like to watch dillusional people.

Anyone else think its kinda weird that a bunch of millionaires are telling other people to deal with poverty?

And that they did this before and it didnt work...
 
Pengwuino said:
Oh man... I don't like to watch dillusional people.

Anyone else think its kinda weird that a bunch of millionaires are telling other people to deal with poverty?

Urrrm, David Gilmour just sold his £3.6 million house, and gave the proceeds to the cause.

And that they did this before and it didnt work...

It did a lot of good, I don't think anyone will argue with that.
 
Really? "Poverty is at an all time high" is all i hear from people. Really working eh...

And let's see... do you REALLY want me to go through and find out the assets these people have? And doesn't the fact that he had a house that expensive in the first place show you a little something?
 
Pengwuino said:
Really? "Poverty is at an all time high" is all i hear from people. Really working eh...

It's helping, I don't see how you can question that.

And let's see... do you REALLY want me to go through and find out the assets these people have? And doesn't the fact that he had a house that expensive in the first place show you a little something?

Urm yes, perhaps something to do with him being a very successful musician? What's that got to do with it anyway? These people have all been working for free to organise and run an absolutely massive event, when was the last time you did that?

Anyway, that's not the point. It's my thread, and I won't tolerate misery gutses! There's a reason I posted this in GD and not Politics, and there's a reason why the OP content was about the concerts and not the cause.
 
I remember the scandal from the last "celebrity" money raising event, 95% of the money went to "compensate" and "accommodate" the celebrities, they weren't "paid" but their airfare, hotels, limos, food, makeup artists, clothing etc...were all paid for out of the money raised, their promoters, all the people associated with "the cause", almost no money got into the hands of the people the money was raised for, but lots of free press for the "celebrities". :rolleyes:

Not to mention the huge tax write off for their "performances".
 
brewnog said:
It's helping, I don't see how you can question that.

Urm yes, perhaps something to do with him being a very successful musician? What's that got to do with it anyway? These people have all been working for free to organise and run an absolutely massive event, when was the last time you did that?

Anyway, that's not the point. It's my thread, and I won't tolerate misery gutses! There's a reason I posted this in GD and not Politics, and there's a reason why the OP content was about the concerts and not the cause.

Your right, this argument is better suited for a different thread.
 
I hadn't even heard of it until this thread. :rolleyes:

What do you mean about the Kaiser Chiefs? I like their music. Is there something crazy they did or something?
 
  • #10
It wasnt about raising money though, live 8 was different to live aid because live 8 has set out to put pressure on the G8 summit to do something about it. It would be almost impossible to raise enough money and to do the right things with it to make a difference to Africa. The people that can make a difference are the leaders of the G8 and its about time they actually did something about it. I thought pink floyd where pretty boring, the Who where awesome though.
 
  • #11
can't believe that even england and germany had better acts then Canada...
 
  • #12
Oh, hmmm...I wonder if that's the concert being televised here now? We have Nascar on one channel, some show about a lawyer bribing judges or something on another channel, and a concert on the third channel. I just turned off the TV to sit outside to eat dinner (the TV was on while I was cooking...I wasn't paying much attention since I was walking in and out to the grill and reading stuff here while it was on).
 
  • #13
neurocomp2003 said:
can't believe that even england and germany had better acts then Canada...
ok the hyde park show was pretty much untouchable, but Canada's lineup was awesome. tragically hip, barenaked ladies, neil young, etc are all Canadian legends. neil young wrote the perfect song for an occasion like this also, keep on rocking in the free world. he wrote it to mock george bush sr ("thousand points of light for the homeless man") but the message is still relevant today. it's too bad sarah mclachlan played philadelphia instead of barrie.