
#1
Jul605, 08:31 PM

P: 76

in the movie "the bank" a mathematical genius predicts the exact movements of the sharemarket after years of research and attempts. he uses Fractal geometry, chaos theory, nonlinear dynamics and of special interest to him was the work of mandelbrot and his work regarding fractals.
He says, "if we can predict [tex]\infty[/tex], then predicting the stock market is easy." Firstly, is this possible? Secondly, To be able to predict the exact movements of the market in a defined 30 minute space for example, before it happens, what inputs would be needed? (like previous price data?, economic probability?) how would it be applied? Thirldy, where is the best place to learn about this mathematics? I am immensley intrested in this and would appreciate any help, Thanks 



#2
Jul605, 08:43 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 1,123

Well, correct me if I am wrong, but stock markets depend on what a lot of experts think. But due to the Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle we would not be able to fully measure such a thing.
We could probably get a lot of approximations of the stock market with varying degrees of accuracy my simplifying the whole thing, but beyond that I don’t see what can be done. 



#3
Jul605, 08:54 PM

P: 76

well excuse my language but this actually is a correct term for traders. a "big swinging dick" is a person who is famous for their trading, and are so closley watched, every thing they do is copied and therefore has an effect on the market. the main forces on the market are supply and demand.
Keeping this in mind, and also "if we can predict [tex]\infty[/tex]" do you think it's possible? 



#4
Jul605, 09:04 PM

P: 1,373

Fractals, Chaos and Nonlinear Dynamics
any school with classes in Neural nets(optional)/ stochastics / markov models and operations reserach shouhld give you the materials you need. Be sure to learn programming as well since this will be your application
...as for inputs like weather and disease you input the prior few years depending on the range of research your doing. mmm i think it was the measles was done at a period of 60 years input 



#5
Jul605, 09:11 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 1,593





#6
Jul605, 09:15 PM

P: 76

would anything else be needed? like probability ect....? 



#7
Jul705, 09:05 AM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 1,123

But yes, these people are very good at "approximating the market", if they knew things exactly then they'd probably be a lot richer.... 



#8
Jul705, 10:03 AM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 9,398

it sounds lke nonsense (predicitng infinity) and is just film making dressing thigns up. dynamical systems and stochastic processes are used to study the markets (what do you think quant analysts do?). there is a limit to any model's accuracy since the mathematics is only an approximation (you realize that the boom of the 80s when people got disgustingly rich was a mathematical one  a bunch of mathematically trianed people figured that they could do a better job of predicting the markets than traders operating on hunches). Heck, you can even do degrees with financial mathematics in them. but to absolutely and completely predict anything with 100% accuracy that is that complicated we know to be impossible, and that isn't even allowing for "human factors" such as a terrorist attack.




#9
Jul805, 09:08 AM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 1,593

You know what, how fitting for such a thread: We got, I don't know, 5 or 6 different models to predict the path of hurricane Dennis and they're all different! Way to go guys . . . I'm watching two butterflies outside of my window right now fluttering aroung the azelaes . . . a storm is brewing . .




#10
Jul805, 12:46 PM

HW Helper
P: 2,874





#11
Jul805, 06:54 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 1,123

Or am I in fact over thinking the situation? 



#12
Jul1005, 07:07 AM

P: 76

he says stuff like, "with this mathematics, things that we never though possible to predict now can be. e.g. cloud formations" also, he is trying to predict "sentiment" in a way.
"all the current methods of prediction do the same thing, try to predict what one person is going to do, but trying to predict what 100 people will do is much much eaiser" He uses fuzzy logic, Mandelbrot fractals, chaos theory, fuzzy logic and nonlinear dynamics. Is it possible to use these things to predict the markets? 



#13
Jul1005, 08:25 AM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 1,123

That is nonsense, what you are able to do is 'approximate' what things are going to do. When you have more data (e.g more people) it means that you take an average that will generally follow a trend, however it means you have to take out the possibility of extreme circumstances. 



#14
Jul1005, 09:26 AM

HW Helper
P: 2,874





#15
Jul1005, 03:38 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 9,398

can we please just dismiss thi sfilm as being a complete load of &$^£*&$&&£ (use your preferred expletive).



Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Nonlinear Dynamics and Chaos  Science & Math Textbook Listings  3  
Non Linear Dynamics & Chaos  Academic Guidance  1  
Graduate nonlinear dynamics/chaos studies  Academic Guidance  2  
Can fractals sum to a linear function?  General Math  9 