Register to reply

Silly proof that 2 = 1? wtf?

by ShawnD
Tags: proof, silly
Share this thread:
ShawnD
#1
Nov3-03, 09:52 PM
Sci Advisor
ShawnD's Avatar
P: 986
In some part of this forum there was a link to silly math proofs such as 10 = 0, 2 = 1, 3 = 4 and so on. I've slightly modified one of those proofs in order to make it tricky to figure out what is wrong.

first of all, A --> B so A and B are almost equal. IIRC, ~ means something like almost equal so I will use it to relate the two.
A ~ B then multiply both sides by A
A^2 ~ AB then subtract B^2 from both sides
A^2 - B^2 ~ AB - B^2 then we factor both sides
(A + B) * (A - B) ~ B * (A - B) now divide both sides by (A - B)
A + B ~ B since A and B are almost equal, let's half *** simplify
B + B ~ B combine like terms
2B ~ B factor out B
2 ~ 1 what the heck?

At the step where both sides are divided by A - B, that is NOT a divide by 0 error. Since A and B are not exactly equal, that operation was perfectly legal.

So where is the flaw here?
Phys.Org News Partner Science news on Phys.org
Flapping baby birds give clues to origin of flight
Prions can trigger 'stuck' wine fermentations, researchers find
Socially-assistive robots help kids with autism learn by providing personalized prompts
Hurkyl
#2
Nov3-03, 10:16 PM
Emeritus
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
Hurkyl's Avatar
P: 16,091
Run through the example with actual numbers, and the flaw will be clear. (and it will be a nice example of numerical instability)

Try, say, A = 1 and B = 1.0001
StephenPrivitera
#3
Nov3-03, 11:18 PM
P: 364
Let's use some real algebra.
Say A=B+k, where k>0 (but is very small)
A2=A(B+k)=AB+Ak
A2-B2=AB+Ak-B2
(A-B)(A+B)=B(A-B)+Ak
A+B=B+Ak/(A-B)
2B+k=B+Ak/(A-B)
2B=B+Ak/(A-B)-k=B+k(A/(A-B)-1)=B+Bk/(A-B)=B(1+k/(A-B))
2=1+k/(A-B)
In your "proof" you ignored the k part. Of course A-B=k, so k/(A-B)=1, but in your "proof" you take k/(A-B)=0.

ShawnD
#4
Nov4-03, 08:10 PM
Sci Advisor
ShawnD's Avatar
P: 986
Silly proof that 2 = 1? wtf?

Ok thanks for clearing that up.


Register to reply

Related Discussions
A silly question ? Special & General Relativity 28
I know this is silly, but I have to ask... General Discussion 13
2 silly questions General Math 10
Seems a little silly... General Math 4
Silly question General Physics 4