Proving One Solution for n^3-n = d^2+d using the Elliptic Method - Learn More!

  • Context: Graduate 
  • Thread starter Thread starter ramsey2879
  • Start date Start date
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
3 replies · 3K views
ramsey2879
Messages
841
Reaction score
3
Someone told me that he heard that there is a proof based on the elliptic method that only one solution in intergers exists for this problem. This is beyond me however as I have no experience in this area. Can anyone lead me to a citation of the proof or tell me how to proceed. P.S. I determined that d has to equal the floor of the square root of n^3-n and that n=6, d=14 is a solution.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
A start on the problem is to notice that 4(d(d+1))+1 = 4d^2+4d+1 = (2d+1)^2.

Thus we have 4N^3-4N+1 = X^2.

Checking for squares up to N=1000, N non-negative, produces only N=0,1,2,6. This suggests that no other solutions exist
 
robert Ihnot said:
A start on the problem is to notice that 4(d(d+1))+1 = 4d^2+4d+1 = (2d+1)^2.

Thus we have 4N^3-4N+1 = X^2.

Checking for squares up to N=1000, N non-negative, produces only N=0,1,2,6. This suggests that no other solutions exist
Yes, you are right I miss some important conditions given in the original problem thst excluded n=0,1,2. In my modification I let n=b in the problem below: Let a, b, c,d,e be integers such that none of them equals 1.
Does there exist a set of three consecutive integers,{a,b,c} and
another set of two consecutive integers, {d,e} such that a*b*c = d*e?
So n=0,1,2 are excluded since then one of a,b,c=1. But then N=-1 appears to be a solution, doesn't it?