cianfa72's latest activity
-
cianfa72 replied to the thread Undergrad Can a Gyroscope in a Satellite Detect Orbit?.Yes, definitely. What I can't see clearly from the video is: was the gyroscope spinning about its axis when the astronaut placed it on... -
cianfa72 replied to the thread Undergrad Can a Gyroscope in a Satellite Detect Orbit?.In this video at 06:30 the astronaut places the gyroscope on the string attached to the walls of the ISS cabin. I'm not sure whether the... -
cianfa72 reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Undergrad Can a Gyroscope in a Satellite Detect Orbit? with
Informative.
Geodesic paths are not curved. They are straight, by definition: geodesics define what "straight" means. Locally, a gyroscope can't... -
cianfa72 reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Undergrad About global inertial frames in GR with
Agree.
"Geodesic deviation" is the wrong term here, it does not apply to worldlines in a congruence. It applies to the spacetime geometry... -
cianfa72 reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Undergrad Physical Interpretation of Frame Field with
Like.
If you can Lie drag a vector field, how to Lie drag the integral curves of that vector field should be obvious. -
cianfa72 replied to the thread Undergrad Physical Interpretation of Frame Field.Do you think the above actually makes sense ? -
cianfa72 replied to the thread Undergrad Physical Interpretation of Frame Field.Ok, indeed. My point was to stress the notion of parallel and FW transport: assign a curve C, a point P on it and a vector V at P (i.e... -
cianfa72 reacted to PAllen's post in the thread Undergrad Physical Interpretation of Frame Field with
Like.
So, FW transport along any curve will preserve all of these properties. Parallel transport will only preserve them along a geodesic. For... -
cianfa72 replied to the thread Undergrad Physical Interpretation of Frame Field.Yes, of course. I'm not asking about specific properties of frame field. I'm asking about the simple case of FW transport of a set of... -
cianfa72 replied to the thread Undergrad Physical Interpretation of Frame Field.No. Given any curve C, a point P on it and a vector V at P one can solve the first-order differential equation for the parallel... -
cianfa72 replied to the thread Undergrad Physical Interpretation of Frame Field.Ah ok, maybe I wasn't very clear in post #22. In the general case (not geodesic curve) for both parallel and FW transport we need to... -
cianfa72 replied to the thread Undergrad Physical Interpretation of Frame Field.I think the same is true for parallel transport since it is defined for any curve including non-geodesic ones. However I never said... -
cianfa72 reacted to PAllen's post in the thread Undergrad Physical Interpretation of Frame Field with
Agree.
But that operation is typically called the exponential map (and is a completely rigorous construct)... -
cianfa72 replied to the thread Undergrad Physical Interpretation of Frame Field.Ok yes. Yes, however the curve C is known (it is the observer's worldline) hence the tangent vector ##\mathbf u## along the curve... -
cianfa72 replied to the thread Undergrad Physical Interpretation of Frame Field.I'm not sure whether the following argument applies to FW transport as well. Take the parallel transport equation along a curve C from...