Dale's latest activity
-
Dale reacted to QuarkyMeson's post in the thread Undergrad Does mass have intrinsic properties apart from inertia? with
Like.
##F_{net} = \frac{dp}{dt}## There, we not only got rid of your confusion but also now have the correct second law in the Newtonian... -
Dale replied to the thread Undergrad Does mass have intrinsic properties apart from inertia?.For the purpose of your question however, it doesn't really matter. Either way gravity is something beyond inertia, either a force or a... -
Dale replied to the thread Undergrad Does mass have intrinsic properties apart from inertia?.You could say something similar in General relativity, but your question was specifically about Newtonian physics. In standard... -
Dale reacted to DaveC426913's post in the thread Undergrad Transit time for a round trip to Alpha Centuri... with
Like.
But why would they be? They'll all have their own peculiar velocities but, on average, that'll balance to near zero WRT Sol/A.Centauri... -
Dale replied to the thread Undergrad Geometrical meaning of ##(dx)^2##. Does ##(dx)^2## represent a point?.I already said: Not the metric. It is indeed easy to go from one to the other, but the line element is a scalar. -
Dale replied to the thread Undergrad Geometrical meaning of ##(dx)^2##. Does ##(dx)^2## represent a point?.Sure, but ##ds^2## is not a coordinate basis covector itself. As you can see from the formula you posted, it is a scalar. -
Dale replied to the thread Undergrad Geometrical meaning of ##(dx)^2##. Does ##(dx)^2## represent a point?.Sorry, I forgot this was the math forum. I was referring to general relativity. ##ds^2## is the line element or spacetime interval and... -
Dale replied to the thread Undergrad Geometrical meaning of ##(dx)^2##. Does ##(dx)^2## represent a point?.True, assuming that ##x## is a coordinate. Something like ##d\tau^2## or ##ds^2## wouldn't be a coordinate basis covector. -
Dale reacted to wrobel's post in the thread Undergrad Geometrical meaning of ##(dx)^2##. Does ##(dx)^2## represent a point? with
Like.
The modern perspective on these questions is that ##dx^i## is a coordinate basis covector (or basis 1-form) on a manifold, dual to the... -
Dale replied to the thread Undergrad Geometrical meaning of ##(dx)^2##. Does ##(dx)^2## represent a point?.Well, if someone chooses to use Leibniz approach then they are justifiably subject to all of the standard criticisms of that approach. -
Dale replied to the thread Undergrad Geometrical meaning of ##(dx)^2##. Does ##(dx)^2## represent a point?.Interesting. In the US it is almost exclusively the “epsilon delta” approach. I don’t think I have ever seen one that teaches Leibniz’s... -
Dale replied to the thread Undergrad Geometrical meaning of ##(dx)^2##. Does ##(dx)^2## represent a point?.Use Robinson's hyperreals instead: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperreal_number#From_Leibniz_to_Robinson Regardless of Leibniz's... -
Dale reacted to Frabjous's post in the thread Undergrad Geometrical meaning of ##(dx)^2##. Does ##(dx)^2## represent a point? with
Like.
It wasn’t until the early 20th century that calculus had all of its i’s dotted and t’s crossed. I would not get hung up on subtle points... -
Dale replied to the thread Graduate Why rotation apparently seems to be absolute?.And I answered that too: Brans Dicke gravity. It is just weird to ask a question, receive answers, and then suggest both that you... -
Dale replied to the thread Graduate Why rotation apparently seems to be absolute?.And that question has been answered. Did you not see the answers above? Especially my answer about “the shortest distance between two...