Recent content by DrDu

  1. D

    Confusion regarding a chemical kinetics problem

    Isn't this a bimolecular reaction?
  2. D

    Some finds of fossil Devonian fungus "Prototaxites"

    Hm, I still have some material, but I would rather prefer to exchange it than to sell it. Best against nematophytes from other sites, but also petrified fungal material.
  3. D

    Counting d-electrons in M(I) transition metals

    Somewhat oversimplified, I think you can assume that all valence electrons in d-block elements are d-electrons if the atom has a positive oxidation number. The reason is that with increasing atomic charge, the atom gets more hydrogen like and the aufbau principle will be followed (i.e. d will be...
  4. D

    B Symbol for temperature on the Fahrenheit scale

    I wholeheartedly agree. But what do you do if you, for example, expect temperature readings in a clinical study from all over the world? I think you should describe as precisely as possible how to interconvert between different scales as possible, because you can't rely on every data manager...
  5. D

    B Symbol for temperature on the Fahrenheit scale

    Maybe it is clearest to explain this differently. The difference between absolute Temperature and Celsius or Fahrenheit is not only a change of units but of scale. For the Celsius scale we define a new quantity $$ t =T-T_0,$$ where ##T_0=273.16\; \mathrm{K}##. ##t## may perfectly well be...
  6. D

    B Symbol for temperature on the Fahrenheit scale

    This seems at variance with the definition of a physical quantity as, e.g. explained in the document cited above: "The value of a physical quantity Q can be expressed as the product of a numerical value {Q} and a unit [Q] Q = {Q} [Q] (1)Neither the name of the physical quantity, nor the symbol...
  7. D

    B Symbol for temperature on the Fahrenheit scale

    Thank you for your answers, I found now that in this IUPAC document . On p. 138 they use ##t_\mathrm{F}## as symbol for temperature on the Fahrenheit scale.
  8. D

    B Symbol for temperature on the Fahrenheit scale

    IUPAC recommends T as the symbol for absolute temperature and t or theta for temperature on the Celsius scale. While Fahrenheit scale is not recommended, it is nevertheless widespread and the question arises if there is a widely accepted symbol for the respective quantity.
  9. D

    Chemistry Why can we differentiate this entropy total derivative with repect to Temperature?

    When I was taught partial derivatives, my prof pointed out to us that there actually is an important difference between thermodynamic notation and mathematical notation: Specifically, we designate for example internal energy always with the letter "U" irrespective whether we assume it to depend...
  10. D

    Some finds of fossil Devonian fungus "Prototaxites"

    Nice tree, indeed. Many important finds of the Silurian and Devonian, including equisitely preserved coalified Prototaxites were found in the Welsh borderland, which is not far from Manchester. Not in vain have the epocs of the Silurian been named LLandovery, Wenlock and Ludlow. I would love to...
  11. D

    I Paradox: Thermodynamic equilibrium does not exist in gravitational fields

    I would call ##T\sqrt{g_{00}}## the thermodynamical temperature and ##T## the local temperature. thermodynamical temperature is a consequence of the zeroth law of thermodynamics (transitivity of thermal equilibrium). There is no reason to think that it does not hold in gravitational systems. The...
  12. D

    I Paradox: Thermodynamic equilibrium does not exist in gravitational fields

    The problem is also how you define temperature. In thermodynamics, systems in thermal equilibrium are defined to have the same temperature. However, this is not the temperature you measure, say, with a mercury thermometer which is the "local temperature". Hence you cannot run a carnot engine...
  13. D

    I Can the polarization bound charge density be expressed in vacuum by a wave function?

    Maybe you can give some more background on your question. In vacuum, there are no bound charges. So it is not clear what you mean.
  14. D

    I Canonical transformation from canonical to kinetic momentum

    You were right pointing out path dependence. Integration of ##p=\nabla_q G## is only possible if ##p## is rotation free. ##p## is essentially ##A##, so we can at best transform away the rotation free part of ##A##. This corresponds to a change to Coulomb gauge.
  15. D

    I Canonical transformation from canonical to kinetic momentum

    In QM, one could formally implement this transformation with the unitary ## U(q,t)=\exp(ie\int Adq)##. Again, this is hard to interpret if the integral over ##q## is multi-valued.
Back
Top