Recent content by Harveyf

  1. H

    Is the Dream State Our Afterlife?

    Ah; so this is where the magus hangs out. Greetings all. Death...soon enough. When I was a bit younger than my almost seventy summers, I read an article regarding the new electron microscope, and its ability to enlarge an image as tiny as the area in our brains which produces the electrical...
  2. H

    Graduate Was Space Present Before the Big Bang or Did It Expand with the Universe?

    Not at all, Magus; happy to receive your response - nothing like parallel wavelengths to make the conversation stimulating. Where, exactly, is the "less physical" forum you allude to? Perhaps I'll stroll over and see what's cooking. Harveyf
  3. H

    Graduate Was Space Present Before the Big Bang or Did It Expand with the Universe?

    I must agree with Chronos on observational evidence as opposed to conjecture. As my life ticks by, I am confronted daily with the marvelous human mind coming up with alternative explanations to observational realities. The universe exhibits its presence to me in absolute terms. Although I am...
  4. H

    Graduate Was Space Present Before the Big Bang or Did It Expand with the Universe?

    Forgive me if I'm misinterpreting what you're saying, but it appears we're [sort of] in agreement on simultaneous spatial expansion and galactic expansion; n'est pas?
  5. H

    Graduate Was Space Present Before the Big Bang or Did It Expand with the Universe?

    When I began to think along these lines which John is alluding to [the fabric of space itself being created, but at a different rate of expansion than the material contained within it], I thought [almost sixty summers ago] the process itself as so outrageous a concept that the suggestion of...
  6. H

    Graduate Was Space Present Before the Big Bang or Did It Expand with the Universe?

    Thank you, Marcus, for your consideration; from what I can see, the essay is most informative, and provides much food for thought. Thank you, again.
  7. H

    Graduate Was Space Present Before the Big Bang or Did It Expand with the Universe?

    Thank you, selfAdjoint. Thus; given that thirteen and a half billion years is the latest estimate for what you call, "zero volume," I take that to mean that the BB occurred at that moment in time, thrusting from a seemingly central core all of the necessary ingredient material that makes up the...
  8. H

    Graduate Was Space Present Before the Big Bang or Did It Expand with the Universe?

    My goodness, but the forum has suddenly erupted with dialectic on ideas in the expansion of space and hyperspheres. I am humbled by the profundity of thought. Then, too, I almost feel grateful that I cannot visualize the mathematical formulae as applied to the quantum physics required to...
  9. H

    Graduate Was Space Present Before the Big Bang or Did It Expand with the Universe?

    Thank you 4Newton: When you speak of a hypersphere, and that the BB began the expansion in all directions at an equal rate, how do you know that content matter is contained in this hypersphere, rather than continuing its expansion in all directions within a space that has no "curves?" What is it...
  10. H

    Graduate Was Space Present Before the Big Bang or Did It Expand with the Universe?

    Phobos; this is scary. I actually comprehend your message. Now I know how limited my mental capacity is. I tried like crazy to understand John's concept. He and Chronos seem to dialogue with ease on matters that cross my eyes. As to that part of your message, that "...it would be fair to say...
  11. H

    Graduate Was Space Present Before the Big Bang or Did It Expand with the Universe?

    John; Two things: 1) I'm glad Einstein said it first; at least my visualization problem emulates a like mind in the field 2) I can't wait to hear your explanation for the ultimate result of the expansion we've been discussing...
  12. H

    Graduate Was Space Present Before the Big Bang or Did It Expand with the Universe?

    John; believe me, I would want to be among the first to assure you that your ideas were right; unfortunately, I cannot "see" the shell analogy in the terms you describe. For the misfit I am, there must be either a different or simpler methodology to explain the seemingly simplistic picture...
  13. H

    Graduate Was Space Present Before the Big Bang or Did It Expand with the Universe?

    I must admit, the manner of your explanations are becoming more "familiar" to my inexperienced thought-processes on this matter of expansion, but may I inquire of you as to list other analogies to help the process along? I still feel like a fledgling in comparison to the ease by which you...
  14. H

    Graduate Was Space Present Before the Big Bang or Did It Expand with the Universe?

    Chilling, if not absolutely fascinating! Gotta tell you this: I was nine years of age when I first had the thought about the "why" of the blackness of space. After seeing two H.G. Wells motion pictures, and staring at the night sky, I responded to my mother's inquiry as to what I was staring at...