Yes I realize this is only a theory, and there is not much evidence to support it, but there is so much we don't know about the universe we live in, something like this could may well be true.
Does anyone believe that the solar system has a second star? There is a theory that the solar system has a second, larger star called Nemesis. It has an oval shaped orbit around the sun, curving very close to the sun and then traveling 1 light year away, interrupting the asteroid belt...
How do scientists know if something is traveling away from us at any given moment, yes, it might be red, but it could be just a red dwarf star? How do they know it is the Doppler Effect in action, not just its natural colour?