iste's latest activity
-
iste replied to the thread Graduate How valid is the indivisible interpretation of quantum mechanics?.Sure, but the quantum dictionary and the Born rule basically have the same form. The difference is kind of trivial, and I think that can... -
iste replied to the thread Graduate How valid is the indivisible interpretation of quantum mechanics?.He is just postulating their existence. There is nothing in the formalism saying that there are multi-time joint probabilities. He is... -
iste replied to the thread Undergrad Particle vs Wave Interpretations of QM.Yes, its definitely a Kuhnian shift as it introduces something that implies a new ontology or metaphysics that didn't exist before. I... -
iste replied to the thread Graduate How valid is the indivisible interpretation of quantum mechanics?.Yes, but Barandes explicitly says that such a process exists underlying the indivisible probabilities. He is saying there is an... -
iste replied to the thread Graduate How valid is the indivisible interpretation of quantum mechanics?.No, the correspondence is between the operator formalism and a conditional probability in a manner no fundamentally different to the... -
iste replied to the thread Graduate How valid is the indivisible interpretation of quantum mechanics?.A stochastic process has to have multi-time joint probabilities. Barandes theory doesn't give you any which means that the... -
iste replied to the thread Graduate How valid is the indivisible interpretation of quantum mechanics?.I don't find anything impalatable with a stochastic picture. I think its probably the most desirable kind of hidden variable... -
iste replied to the thread Graduate How valid is the indivisible interpretation of quantum mechanics?.Its only not a deficiency if you think its trivial to construct a stochastic process that fulfils all the properties you want it to with... -
iste reacted to Fra's post in the thread Graduate How valid is the indivisible interpretation of quantum mechanics? with
Like.
I now listened to the key part where Albert keeps asking what is the fundamental law but isn't satisfied with Barandes saying "it's just... -
iste replied to the thread Graduate How valid is the indivisible interpretation of quantum mechanics?.Well, they could be lawlike, Barandes isn't specifying whether they are lawlike or not because he doesn't have any access to them... -
iste replied to the thread Graduate How valid is the indivisible interpretation of quantum mechanics?.On that same video there are statements of the sort all through about 1:17 to 1:46, and quite a clear concise summary from about 1:42 -... -
iste replied to the thread Graduate How valid is the indivisible interpretation of quantum mechanics?.I might try to find exactly where in videos but pretty sure Barandes talks about the towers of probabilities for a stochastic process... -
iste replied to the thread Graduate How valid is the indivisible interpretation of quantum mechanics?. -
iste reacted to gentzen's post in the thread Graduate How valid is the indivisible interpretation of quantum mechanics? with
Like.
The discussion did not just "feel" more substantive. What I have watched so far (~1h 43min) was factually a lot more substantive than...