Recent content by javisot

  1. J

    Graduate Black Hole Fragmentation

    I would like to ask about the recent article https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.24642 "when black holes can wear pants". This article discusses the "fragmentation" of black holes. We know that two black holes can merge into one, accompanied by the emission of gravitational waves; the article addresses...
  2. J

    Undergrad Gerard 't Hooft on the incompleteness of quantum mechanics

    The "right" question would be, as martinbn rightly points out: which "interpretation" will write in physcis book as correct version? The answer is none, because the textbook deals with formalism, not interpretations. Even if it did cover interpretations, there is no single one that could be...
  3. J

    AI Avoiding AI hallucinations in science problem solving

    By asking very simple questions. If the task you assign it becomes increasingly complex, it will inevitably end up hallucinating. The challenge lies in developing an AI that does not hallucinate and is truly general, something that does not seem possible.
  4. J

    High School Why light can travel at c?

    We can study the propagation of light in a vacuum without considering the source that originated it.
  5. J

    High School Why light can travel at c?

    What source exists for light in a vacuum?
  6. J

    Undergrad Gerard 't Hooft on the incompleteness of quantum mechanics

    The title was "shut up and calculate", a title that had nothing to do with the development of the thread.
  7. J

    Undergrad Gerard 't Hooft on the incompleteness of quantum mechanics

    Do you think Gerard goes further than BM? I mean, BM respects the UP (he treats it differently, but he respects it). Gerard seems to deny the UP, therefore, he concludes "QM is wrong".
  8. J

    Undergrad Gerard 't Hooft on the incompleteness of quantum mechanics

    Correct me if I'm wrong, Demystifier. In BM, evolution is deterministic: if we knew the wave function and the initial configuration of all particles exactly, the equations would determine their subsequent evolution. However, this does not imply that we can know all those initial conditions or...
  9. J

    Undergrad Gerard 't Hooft on the incompleteness of quantum mechanics

    You seemed to agree with this statement. But you seem to disagree with this other one, and the curious thing is that both statements say the same thing.
  10. J

    Undergrad Gerard 't Hooft on the incompleteness of quantum mechanics

    I simply used the dictionary definition: "The word fundamental means serving as a basic, central, or essential foundation upon wich other things develop os depend" In this sense, no interpretation is free from randomness in its formalism.
  11. J

    Undergrad Gerard 't Hooft on the incompleteness of quantum mechanics

    I see that we all agree that an interpretation of QM without randomness (neither apparent nor fundamental) cannot reproduce all the results, then it cannot be an interpretation of QM. Therefore, we all agree that every interpretation of QM contains randomness, whether fundamental or apparent...
  12. J

    Undergrad Gerard 't Hooft on the incompleteness of quantum mechanics

    Let’s reach an agreement, because I am confused: an interpretation of QM that includes randomness in some sense cannot fully correspond to a version that does not include randomness in any sense. An interpretation of QM that does not include randomness in any sense fails to account for the UP...
  13. J

    Undergrad Gerard 't Hooft on the incompleteness of quantum mechanics

    We are not using the term "apparent" in the same way. In the case of a coin toss, the randomness is apparent (not real), due to the lack of information that exists. In quantum mechanics, the randomness is not apparent; it is fundamental.
  14. J

    Undergrad Gerard 't Hooft on the incompleteness of quantum mechanics

    In the coin example, the randomness is only apparent due to lack of information. In quantum mechanics, is the randomness only apparent to you?
  15. J

    Undergrad Gerard 't Hooft on the incompleteness of quantum mechanics

    All I wanted to say is that the coin example doesn't seem like the best example.