mathwonk's latest activity
-
Mmathwonk replied to the thread Some thoughts about self-education.Here is what I learned from reading Riemann. Recall the Riemann- Roch theorem is a formula for the vector dimension of the space L(D) of...
-
Mmathwonk replied to the thread Some thoughts about self-education.@martinbn: Riemann's original discussion is reproduced on pages 105-108 of: the dover reprint of Riemann’s works in the original...
-
Mmathwonk reacted to Gavran's post in the thread Is this the correct general solution of the given PDE? with
Like.
Your method and your result in the original post are correct because every partial differential equation that only involves derivatives... -
Mmathwonk replied to the thread Some thoughts about self-education.I think vela hit the nail on the head. Becoming educated, i.e. learning to understand something, is for me a long, difficult process...
-
Mmathwonk replied to the thread Some thoughts about self-education.As a high school student long ago in the US south our school offered no calculus, very inadequate algebra and geometry, and the local...
-
MThe music teacher gave my math workbook to my class teacher who then had a talk with me after class. I promised not to do math during...
-
MOne thought that occurs to me is that virtually all learning is self-learning. If you enroll in a course and listen to the lectures but...
-
Mmathwonk reacted to Hill's post in the thread High School The parallel axiom, Stillwell's "Reverse Mathematics" with
Like.
We don't know what he had in mind, but as a matter of fact, existence of parallel lines does not require the parallel axiom and what the... -
Mmathwonk replied to the thread High School The parallel axiom, Stillwell's "Reverse Mathematics".Here is the situation as I understand it. Stillwell states Euclid's parallel postulate, then gives an argument meant to prove its...
-
Mmathwonk replied to the thread High School The parallel axiom, Stillwell's "Reverse Mathematics".yes, my drawing labeled the angles oppositely to Stillwell. I have (hopefully) corrected the notation in response to your observation...
-
Mmathwonk replied to the thread High School The parallel axiom, Stillwell's "Reverse Mathematics".But let's try to prove existence of parallels actually using Euclid's parallel postulate. let p be the point where n meets m in his...
-
Mmathwonk replied to the thread High School The parallel axiom, Stillwell's "Reverse Mathematics".Having found and read Stillwell's account in full, I agree with you that he seems mistaken in his claim. I find that very puzzling, as...
-
Mmathwonk replied to the thread High School The parallel axiom, Stillwell's "Reverse Mathematics".I can't judge a book's logical flow based on selected excerpts. But the ones you have reproduced do puzzle me. If Stillwell is...
-
Mmathwonk replied to the thread High School The parallel axiom, Stillwell's "Reverse Mathematics".Well again, I am handicapped by not having the book. He visibly states that the result follows from the ASA principle, so that is what...
-
Mmathwonk replied to the thread High School The parallel axiom, Stillwell's "Reverse Mathematics".It does not appear to be used here. I can only suppose that he does not mean this latter fact actually follows from the parallel...