Motore's latest activity
-
MMotore reacted to Morbert's post in the thread Graduate Entanglement swapping and Bohmian mechanics with
Like.
You keep trying to move off the point, which will just result in mistakes compounding mistakes. It is not cherry picking to point out Ma... -
MMotore reacted to DrChinese's post in the thread Graduate Entanglement swapping and Bohmian mechanics with
Sad.
Yes, the swap changes the state. By way of ongoing analogy: If I have a single |V> 401 nm photon headed into a suitable PDC crystal... -
MMotore reacted to DrChinese's post in the thread Graduate Entanglement swapping and Bohmian mechanics with Sad.
1. You have no idea how funny that sounds - can't use full quote. I'll have to try using partial quotes in the future. :smile: 2...
-
MMotore reacted to DrChinese's post in the thread Graduate Entanglement swapping and Bohmian mechanics with Sad.
Why won't you give the full quote? Now you are doing the cherry-picking thing too. Ma: "...As schematically shown in Fig. 1, if [and...
-
MMotore reacted to DrChinese's post in the thread Graduate Entanglement swapping and Bohmian mechanics with Sad.
The 2 and 3 photons emerge from the Bell-state measurement entangled in one of 4 Bell states. Oh, am I making unsubstantiated claims...
-
MMotore reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Graduate Entanglement swapping and Bohmian mechanics with Like.
No, he doesn't. Again, this is the meaning you are putting on other words Ma says. None of Ma's actual words that you quoted, or...
-
MMotore reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Graduate Entanglement swapping and Bohmian mechanics with Like.
Of course. Nobody has disputed that. And we are not doing any such thing. You are not arguing with us at all at this point. You are...
-
MMotore reacted to DrChinese's post in the thread Graduate Entanglement swapping and Bohmian mechanics with Sad.
1. It's literally the definition of cherry picking. Read and quote Ma's entire paragraph. Or Megidish. 2. I am quite comfortable with...
-
MMotore reacted to Morbert's post in the thread Graduate Entanglement swapping and Bohmian mechanics with Like.
Ma says "This can be seen by rewriting Eq. (1) in the basis of Bell states of photons 2 and 3.". I am not picking apart anything. I...
-
MMotore reacted to DrChinese's post in the thread Graduate Entanglement swapping and Bohmian mechanics with Sad.
No, actually, Ma explicitly says this - and not just your cherry-picked sentence: ... (1) "...As schematically shown in Fig. 1, if...
-
MMotore reacted to DrChinese's post in the thread Graduate Entanglement swapping and Bohmian mechanics with Sad.
And for the zillionth time: You keeping ignoring the crucial point, in the literal words of Ma: State (1) -> Swap -> State (2) Ma: "As...
-
MMotore reacted to Morbert's post in the thread Graduate Entanglement swapping and Bohmian mechanics with Like.
I'm not moving off this point until you acknowledge it. Ma explicitly says (2) is a rewriting of (1) in a Bell basis. You keep writing...
-
MMotore reacted to Morbert's post in the thread Graduate Entanglement swapping and Bohmian mechanics with Like.
What Ma actually says is (2) is arrived at by "rewriting Eq. (1) in the basis of Bell states of photons 2 and 3" (Ma's exact words)...
-
MMotore reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Graduate Entanglement swapping and Bohmian mechanics with Like.
This is true. I put that in bold to make sure it's clear. I agree with this statement. However, I do not agree with this. Here's why...
-
MMotore reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Graduate Entanglement swapping and Bohmian mechanics with Like.
As @Sambuco said, there's no "think" about it. It's a mathematical proof. It's the same algebra that I had already done before I posted...