Recent content by obtronix

  1. O

    High School Can the same ruler have two different sizes?

    From someone else's inertial reference frame perspective there are an infinite number of possible ruler sizes, this is no different than me measuring a tree at different angles or at different distances and measuring different tree heights. In special relativity spacetime rotation is due to...
  2. O

    Undergrad Can Propeller Speeds and Wave Breaks Challenge the Speed of Light?

    1. There's no such thing as a rigid object think of the propellers as more slinky like at high speeds. 2. No information is being transferred at the speed of light. It's just an illusion of faster than light speed.
  3. O

    Undergrad Twin paradox, virtual clock on ship with Earth time, discontinuity

    Your graphs both look correct, in special relativity a change in the ship's inertial frames will cause a time jump in "earth time", the fact that acceleration caused it is kind of irrelevant it's the change in inertial frame that matters. It results in a path change and a slope greater than 1...
  4. O

    Undergrad Double slit as a function of time

    It's a quantum mechanics postulate that the particle is in a super position state. With different probabilities for different positions when observed. This postulate cannot be derived from a set of variables.
  5. O

    High School What is x' for Moving Rocket from P?

    Yes it can be negative In the below space-time diagram enter .6 for velocity, 0 for x, 4 for t for event B. You will see a negative x' for event B, x' = -3, t'=5 http://www.trell.org/div/minkowski.html
  6. O

    High School Time dilation - what is the time on the Earth?

    There's a symmetry here, the measurements are only valid in their own reference frame. If I walk away from you you measure me smaller and I measure you smaller it seems contradictory until you realize the measurements are only valid from their perspective. Likewise in relativity space twin...
  7. O

    High School Understanding twin paradox without math

    "suddenly skips ahead in time" is almost never accepted as a reasonable answer by most people, I suppose you need to introduce the block universe and angled slices idk "Earth-twin's answer to the question "what time does the rocket-twin's wristwatch display right now?" never changes...
  8. O

    High School Understanding twin paradox without math

    Not a different scenario a different point of view, everybody will be traveling exactly in the same way, same speed same distance, just the handoffs of times will be different.With the original twin paradox thought experiment you get the same answer from everyone's perspective.
  9. O

    High School Understanding twin paradox without math

    My diagrams have acceleration in them! He's creating a "ghost being" that is jumping from one ship to the other without accelerating. So he's kind of adding apples with oranges intervals. If you think that's untrue what makes A so different than B and C? Relativity says motion is relative. I...
  10. O

    High School Understanding twin paradox without math

    Okay he doesn't say that but maybe he misspoke. But I could assume C at rest, perform similar SpaceTime interval calculations, and have them record the longest time.
  11. O

    High School Understanding twin paradox without math

    Well that's not true he's saying you start the clocks simultaneously and measure time from that start. (e.g. spaceship C to event 2).
  12. O

    High School Understanding twin paradox without math

    Yes but where/when does the thought experiment start and end in his thought experiment? To compare World lines you need a start and ending event. The twin paradox gives you those two events. He says in the beginning of his thought experiment everyone sets their clock to zero, but they're all...
  13. O

    High School Understanding twin paradox without math

    But that's not the twin paradox thought experiments because they not are together to begin with and they never meet up at the end. They would have to jump for one spaceship to another which is acceleration. In any event to have different velocities they would have to accelerate he just kind of...
  14. O

    High School Understanding twin paradox without math

    I mean it's instantaneous so it has to be discontinuous.