PAllen's latest activity
-
PPAllen replied to the thread High School Estimates — True Size of the Universe?.Actually, it is only a possible property of very special spacetimes. It is a feature of geometry that is hard to visualize in a 3x1...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread High School Estimates — True Size of the Universe?.I’ve used the following analogy to picture an infinite expanding universe. Consider the universe as an (countably) infinite collection...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread High School Am I understanding the concept of proper frame of reference?.I found an explicit statement in this section of MTW (13.6 bottom of p. 331 in my edition) that makes clear that they have the meaning I...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread High School Am I understanding the concept of proper frame of reference?.The wording “proper reference frame of an accelerated observer” implies, in ordinary English, the notion of proper reference frame of a...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread High School Am I understanding the concept of proper frame of reference?.Well, MTW calls it the proper reference frame of an accelerated observer, implying that a standard inertial frame is the proper...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Undergrad Question about Parallel Transport.No, that's not the issue I realized. You have a piece of ##E^2## embedded in ##S^3##, all embedded in ##E^4##. I was thinking that a...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Undergrad Question about Parallel Transport.What I was thinking of here was based on the 3-sphere embedded in ##E^4## being able to contain a surface that is metrically ##E^2##...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Undergrad Question about Parallel Transport.I am saying this is not necessarily true. True is that you can find a hypersurface containing it such it is a geodesic of the...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Undergrad Question about Parallel Transport.I am not sure that is always true. Consider, by analogy, a 3-sphere embedded in Euclidean 4 space. It can contain a geodesic of the...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Undergrad Question about Parallel Transport.Yes.
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Undergrad Question about Parallel Transport.Actually, if you take any small part of the geodesic, and a small neighborhood around that part, then that geodesic segment is minimal -...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Undergrad Question about Parallel Transport.True, but that is just a recipe for constructing a pure Riemannian manifold, that happens to a submanifold. So it is actually covered in...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Undergrad Question about Parallel Transport.No, not longest distance - you can deviate from a non minimal great circle path and make it longer - by any amount with squiggles. In...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread High School Thought Experiment: Behavior of shadow of object moving at speed c.Let’s keep in mind that the shadow would have to be 300 meters for a one microsecond delay between front and back. I don’t think the...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread High School Thought Experiment: Behavior of shadow of object moving at speed c.Consider the scenario for a slow moving object (close to a screen, far away flash bulb). What do you see? How is the fast moving object...