Recent content by PAllen
-
P
Undergrad Gerard 't Hooft on the incompleteness of quantum mechanics
Instantaneous interaction and apparent communication are interpretation dependent. The only observable is a correlation that can be detected when all contributing components are in the past light cone of the observed correlation. All else is interpretation.- PAllen
- Post #121
- Forum: Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
-
P
Undergrad Is GR superior to Newtonian gravity?
it was certainly suspected from SR because light has momentum in SR, and if absorbed contributes to rest mass. So this non inclusion would be suspect.- PAllen
- Post #55
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
P
Undergrad Is GR superior to Newtonian gravity?
Just as an aside - one of the ways to address binding energy directly in GR is to assume, for a large local system, e.g, a galaxy, you can approximately assume it is embedded in asymptotically flat space time. Then, as a system evolves from a widely separated state to a bound state, the decline...- PAllen
- Post #53
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
P
Undergrad Is GR superior to Newtonian gravity?
Yes, to some extent it gets around my criticism - the trace of T is obviously a Lorentz scalar, and it avoids instant changes at a distance from local changes. However, by having EM radiation not source gravity, it does not meet the requirements that all energy contributes to gravity. Because it...- PAllen
- Post #52
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
P
Undergrad Is GR superior to Newtonian gravity?
But total mass/energy is a source in a relativistic gravity theory, and that is definitely NOT a Lorentz scalar. For example, a system of bodies of the same total rest mass, but with differing kinetic energy will attract something else differently. This establishes that you must include kinetic...- PAllen
- Post #43
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
P
Undergrad Is GR superior to Newtonian gravity?
The Newtonian potential depends position, and this is mathematically incompatible with special relativity because any local change has an instant global effect. Even more generally, a scalar potential would necessarily depend on Lorentz scalars to be consistent with SR. But the only plausible...- PAllen
- Post #32
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
P
Undergrad Is GR superior to Newtonian gravity?
You seem to have completely missed my point. You were complaining “where is the potential in GR”. I explain there can’t possibly be anything like a Newtonian potential in a relativistic theory of gravity, and point out that GR is closer to EM in this regard. Now being exactly like EM is a...- PAllen
- Post #25
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
P
Undergrad Is GR superior to Newtonian gravity?
The Newtonian scalar potential is associated with action at a distance and absence of gravitational radiation. Thus the potential is wrong when these issues become significant. Instead, you can make GR have a close analogy to EM with gravitoelectromagnetism, because EM supports waves and goes...- PAllen
- Post #18
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
P
Graduate Hau, Harris, Tsakmakidis for 2026 Nobel in Physics?
Unfortunately, while I have been hoping for Hau for many years (I met her once at a talk), I have developed the opinion that the Nobel committee has some blind spot. There have been so many years when she would have be an obvious choice over those chosen, IMO. So I have given up hope.- PAllen
- Post #6
- Forum: Other Physics Topics
-
P
AI Is AI Overhyped?
One thing that, to me shows a missing element of actual understanding, is the completely unique mistakes the top bots still make (as of March 2026, using the premiere paid version of each) playing chess. Most humans will miscalculate or miss simple tactics. They will never decide “it would be...- PAllen
- Post #493
- Forum: Computing and Technology
-
P
AI Is AI Overhyped?
Here is another one for comparison between free Claude.ai and the paid version. The free version analyzes the following incorrectly: “Consider a baseball at rest, and another rapidly moving one aimed to miss it by 6 inches. Consider that the gamma factor of the approaching baseball is 10^54...- PAllen
- Post #482
- Forum: Computing and Technology
-
P
AI Is AI Overhyped?
On the other hand, here is a financial example free Claude gets wrong, and the prompt needed to correct it: “I want to use an SBLOC to fund part of a down payment for a conventional mortgage application. How will this be treated?” It will spout incorrect information about interest on the LOC...- PAllen
- Post #477
- Forum: Computing and Technology
-
P
AI Is AI Overhyped?
Note, 3 test problems I gave Claude 6 months ago that it got wrong, it now gets right. These had to do with local, smooth, isometric embeddings.- PAllen
- Post #476
- Forum: Computing and Technology
-
P
AI Is AI Overhyped?
Here is one. Note, I get varying answers at different times, but all neglect to correctly describe the extreme anisotropy of what happens to the solar system. By not conceptually understanding that most of the solar system would see the collision highly attenuated (though still very extreme) the...- PAllen
- Post #474
- Forum: Computing and Technology
-
P
AI Is AI Overhyped?
How different are the paid versions from the free versions? I have used the free versions of chat gpt, claude, and gemini. All leave me unimpressed whether trying a technical discussion or an economic simulation. I find a glaring error every other page or so of conversation. I actually do find...- PAllen
- Post #471
- Forum: Computing and Technology