Sylvain9595's latest activity
-
SSylvain9595 replied to the thread Undergrad Unexpected findings in need of an explanation (retrograde motion of Mars).Of course, I never thought that my 2D animation could represent the real 3D loops, it's just the "mirror effect" that I didn't expect.
-
SSylvain9595 reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Undergrad Unexpected findings in need of an explanation (retrograde motion of Mars) with
Like.
The loops are not representing the complete path of Mars in an Earth-centered frame. They are representing the apparent position of Mars... -
SSylvain9595 reacted to DaveC426913's post in the thread Undergrad Unexpected findings in need of an explanation (retrograde motion of Mars) with
Like.
This is what I was saying, yes. -
SSylvain9595 replied to the thread Undergrad Unexpected findings in need of an explanation (retrograde motion of Mars).No it is not, here's another retrogradation of Mars with the dates : Anyway, even if your image was upside down, the loop would still...
-
SSylvain9595 replied to the thread Undergrad Unexpected findings in need of an explanation (retrograde motion of Mars).Wait a second, we did solve the problem I outlined in my first message, but now I've run into an even bigger one! Here's the actual...
-
SSylvain9595 replied to the thread Undergrad Unexpected findings in need of an explanation (retrograde motion of Mars).It is very clear now, I guess I needed a visualisation. Thanks again.
-
SSylvain9595 reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Undergrad Unexpected findings in need of an explanation (retrograde motion of Mars) with
Like.
Because, as my post #32 shows, it affects the distance that each planet travels perpendicular to the line of opposition (the major axis... -
SSylvain9595 reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Undergrad Unexpected findings in need of an explanation (retrograde motion of Mars) with
Like.
I've tried constructing an approximate model by using small segments of circles to approximate the elliptical planetary orbits near... -
SSylvain9595 reacted to DaveC426913's post in the thread Undergrad Unexpected findings in need of an explanation (retrograde motion of Mars) with
Like.
That's a darned impressive animation @Sylvain9595! Did you write that yourself? For those that don't follow the provided link, here is... -
SSylvain9595 reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Undergrad Unexpected findings in need of an explanation (retrograde motion of Mars) with
Like.
No, it starts before opposition. That's obvious from the ephemeris data on JPL Horizons; the reversal of both right ascension and... -
SSylvain9595 replied to the thread Undergrad Unexpected findings in need of an explanation (retrograde motion of Mars).You can thank the Claude AI for that, I just gave her the instructions ;)
-
SSylvain9595 reacted to WernerQH's post in the thread Undergrad Unexpected findings in need of an explanation (retrograde motion of Mars) with
Like.
Minutes in right ascension (RA) are minutes of time, not minutes of arc. One hour in RA corresponds to 15 degrees, but only for motion... -
SSylvain9595 replied to the thread Undergrad Unexpected findings in need of an explanation (retrograde motion of Mars).I have to admit you're right! I've created a better animation: Configuration 1 (2003): Earth-Mars distance = 8, Earth's speed = 1.14...
-
SSylvain9595 replied to the thread Undergrad Unexpected findings in need of an explanation (retrograde motion of Mars).@PeterDonis, I still don't understand why the speed would change the amplitude. There seem to be a problem here : Mars's apparent...
-
SSylvain9595 replied to the thread Undergrad Unexpected findings in need of an explanation (retrograde motion of Mars).I admit you are right, I get it now. I was too focused on the retrograde motion for some reason...




