weirdoguy's latest activity
-
weirdoguy reacted to fresh_42's post in the thread Physics How to close the gap: From Independent Research to Academic Discourse with
Like.
We are judging people by their knowledge. This includes: current state of science, failed attempts in the past, current attempts, the... -
weirdoguy reacted to Esim Can's post in the thread Physics How to close the gap: From Independent Research to Academic Discourse with
Skeptical.
This is not a serious argument really. First the chances are not zero. Even if it is 8 billion people to 1, where is the point in... -
weirdoguy reacted to Esim Can's post in the thread Physics How to close the gap: From Independent Research to Academic Discourse with Skeptical.
@Dale I understand your point, but this is exactly why I distinguish between peer review and arXiv moderation. You describe how you...
-
weirdoguy reacted to Dale's post in the thread Physics How to close the gap: From Independent Research to Academic Discourse with Like.
And you believe the rejection was misusing power? You are simply mistaken if you think you have foundational work with only 9 relevant...
-
weirdoguy reacted to Dale's post in the thread Physics How to close the gap: From Independent Research to Academic Discourse with Like.
First, that is assuming that rejecting a specific paper is a misuse of their power rather than the intended and proper use of their...
-
weirdoguy reacted to Esim Can's post in the thread Physics How to close the gap: From Independent Research to Academic Discourse with
Sad.
@Stavros Kiri Thank you for your advice. Yes i did exactly as you said, because it is the reasonable way to go. Fortunately i now work... -
weirdoguy reacted to PeroK's post in the thread Physics How to close the gap: From Independent Research to Academic Discourse with Like.
Aka "a reality check".
-
weirdoguy reacted to Stavros Kiri's post in the thread Physics How to close the gap: From Independent Research to Academic Discourse with Skeptical.
I would focuss too on preliminary discussions, first, perhaps before you even made any other attempts; the/your first goal, in my...
-
weirdoguy reacted to Stavros Kiri's post in the thread Physics How to close the gap: From Independent Research to Academic Discourse with Skeptical.
Partially Arbitrary assumptions and/or conclusions ... [and perhaps unnecessary "attack" on the OP ...]
-
weirdoguy reacted to WWGD's post in the thread Physics How to close the gap: From Independent Research to Academic Discourse with Skeptical.
Even if you made some valid points, you did so in an unnecessarily cruel way. Others said something similar , clearly, without the need...
-
weirdoguy reacted to Dale's post in the thread Physics How to close the gap: From Independent Research to Academic Discourse with Like.
I am going based on your own description of your work. Have you described it accurately? If your description is accurate then my...
-
weirdoguy reacted to Esim Can's post in the thread Physics How to close the gap: From Independent Research to Academic Discourse with
Haha.
Says the admin, which does not know or did not looked at the paper. Lets make a deal, if you all want. After it is published and... -
weirdoguy reacted to Dale's post in the thread Physics How to close the gap: From Independent Research to Academic Discourse with Like.
I want to emphasize this. IMO, this is the big problem with the OP's efforts. They are deliberately disconnecting their work from the...
-
weirdoguy reacted to Esim Can's post in the thread Physics How to close the gap: From Independent Research to Academic Discourse with Skeptical.
@fresh_42 You are judging not on the base of knowledge as long as you do not have enough data of the knowledge of the person. As i said...
-
weirdoguy reacted to PeroK's post in the thread Physics How to close the gap: From Independent Research to Academic Discourse with Like.
Let's suppose I became an editor and to begin with I took every submission seriously. I would read them fully and give the author a...