Does the Light's One/Two-Way Speed Distinction Mean Anything?

  • I
  • Thread starter Pony
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Speed
In summary: It is not a fact, but it is a convention. In summary, the conversation discusses the concept of trivial metaphysical freedom in relation to the fact that people living in a world must use their own measuring devices. This freedom also applies to choosing clock synchronizations, which is a convenient choice of coordinates and does not affect physical reality. The conversation also touches on the idea of unmeasurable aspects of reality and how they do not play a role in physics. Overall, the conversation emphasizes the importance of understanding conventions and their role in scientific theories.
  • #1
Pony
39
10
There is a trivial metaphysical freedom, that emerges from the fact that people living in a world must use their own measuring devices, that are part of that world.

E.g. people living in a flatland must use their own rulers to measure distance. If one half of their world is widened, they won't notice it if they go there, because they themselves and their rulers will widen too.
( In other words, there is a "true" physics and reality, and there is what they measure and these two differ. Also the former is not measurable, or affect their life in any way. Also the flatland people can choose to believe that half of their world is bigger but unmeasurable, if they want to. )

Now my question. Wiki says that
Albert Einstein chose a synchronization convention (see Einstein synchronization) that made the one-way speed equal to the two-way speed. The constancy of the one-way speed in any given inertial frame is the basis of his special theory of relativity, although all experimentally verifiable predictions of this theory do not depend on that convention.[1][2]
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-way_speed_of_light
Is the ability to choose synchronizations is a relevant and interesting fact, or it is the same of the rather trivial metaphysical argument, that I wrote about above?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
I recommend this video before asking that question.
 
  • Skeptical
Likes Dale
  • #3
If I understand what you are asking, one answer is this: It all seems academic and only for nerds until someone follows the theory through to develop a nuclear weapon.
 
  • #4
Pony said:
Is the ability to choose synchronizations is a relevant and interesting fact,
Being able to choose clock synchronisation is one aspect of the fact that you are free to choose coordinates. If you were not free to choose coordinates you would have to provide some explanation of why your choice of "plane of constant time" was not a free choice, or abandon (or never develop, more likely) spacetime as a model of reality.
 
  • Like
Likes vanhees71 and Pony
  • #5
Pony said:
Also the former is not measurable, or affect their life in any way.
If it is not falsifiable, then it is not physics. However, this is not what is going on with the one-way speed of light. The one-way speed of light can be defined to be equal to the two-way speed and isotropic. This is not saying anything about a physical reality. It is just a conventient choice of coordinates. You could have chosen a different way to assign coordinates and the result would be the same. It is just a more convenient way of assigning the coordinates.

Similarly, you can choose to describe a rectangle with polar coordinates. It is an inconvenient choice though and Cartesian coordinates would probably have been better suited. Using polar coordinates would however not change the physical properties of the rectangle, just be a different way to describe the same thing.

Pony said:
If one half of their world is widened
As defined how? If it is not measurable it is not part of the physical reality of flatland. If you need to postulate that something is unmeasurable, then it has nothing to do with physics.
 
  • Like
Likes vanhees71
  • #6
Pony said:
Is the ability to choose synchronizations is a relevant and interesting fact, or it is the same of the rather trivial metaphysical argument, that I wrote about above?
I would say neither. It is a convention. Neither particularly relevant nor is it a true or false physics. It is simply a convention like the proton’s charge being positive.
 
  • Like
Likes cianfa72, dextercioby, Ibix and 1 other person

FAQ: Does the Light's One/Two-Way Speed Distinction Mean Anything?

1. What is the light's one/two-way speed distinction?

The light's one/two-way speed distinction refers to the difference in speed of light when traveling in one direction versus traveling in the opposite direction. This distinction is based on the assumption that the speed of light is constant in a vacuum and is not affected by the motion of the source or observer.

2. Does the light's one/two-way speed distinction have any practical applications?

Yes, the light's one/two-way speed distinction is important in the field of astronomy and in the study of the universe. It helps us understand the concept of relative motion and the effects of time dilation. It also plays a role in the development of theories such as the theory of relativity.

3. How is the light's one/two-way speed distinction measured?

The light's one/two-way speed distinction is measured using various techniques such as the Michelson-Morley experiment, the Kennedy-Thorndike experiment, and the Sagnac effect. These experiments involve measuring the time it takes for light to travel in different directions and comparing the results.

4. Is the light's one/two-way speed distinction a proven concept?

Yes, the light's one/two-way speed distinction has been proven through various experiments and is a fundamental concept in physics. It is supported by the theory of relativity and has been confirmed by numerous observations and experiments.

5. What are the implications of the light's one/two-way speed distinction?

The light's one/two-way speed distinction has significant implications in our understanding of the universe and the laws of physics. It challenges our traditional understanding of time and space and has led to the development of theories such as the theory of relativity. It also has practical applications in fields such as astronomy and satellite navigation.

Similar threads

Back
Top