Finding velocity at a point on a circular path from energy conservation

  • Thread starter Miike012
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Word problem
28 replies · 4K views · last reply
Miike012
Messages
1,009
Reaction score
0
I added two pictures.. One of the word problem and one of my diagram I made..

My work:

1.Wnet = Kf - Ki
-Ugf = Kf... -mgy = mv^2/2 ... - gy = v^2/2

2. x^2 + y^2 = 1780^2
dy/dx = -x/y = velocity (v) at point (x,y)

3. gy = x^2/(2y^2)

4. gy = (1780^2 - y^2)/(2y^2)

... anyways... I know this must be totally wrong..

Can someone please help me answer this problem?
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of Tarzan on a vine: he hangs from a tree trunk at the left with the vine initially horizontal, then swings down to a lower position; the vine length is labeled l, the angle θ is marked at the pivot, and a vertical drop labeled l sin θ is shown.
    TARZAN.jpg
    11.9 KB · Views: 465
  • Free-body diagram of a point (x,y) on a circle centred at the origin, with tension T pointing to the centre, its components Tx and Ty, and weight w pointing straight down. Equation shown: x^2 + y^2 = 1780^2.
    Graph.png
    7.3 KB · Views: 523
Hi Miike012! :smile:

I have difficulty making sense of what you did.
What do the dots for instance mean in (1)?

And if x and y are coordinates in (2), how did you relate them to a force of 1780 N.
These things have different units and can not be compared...

Anyway, let's start with the relevant equations.
1. Conservation of kinetic and potential energy
2. Centripetal acceleration

Can you write those in formula form?

Next is the decomposition of the forces into aligned forces.
Which forces are there to start with?
 
1.Wnet = delta K
Ugi - Ugf = Kf - Ki
-Ugf = Kf

-gy = v^2/2

2.a = v^2/r

3. SumFy = Ty - w = (m)(ay)
4. SumFx = Tx = (m)(ax)

Are these correct equations?
 
"And if x and y are coordinates in (2), how did you relate them to a force of 1780 N."

I related 1780 to (x,y) by saying the end point of tension started at the origin, and because the motion is a circle I gave the following equation...
x^2 + y^2 = 1780^2... which relates it to x and y... would this not be correct?
 
Miike012 said:
1.Wnet = delta K
Ugi - Ugf = Kf - Ki
-Ugf = Kf

-gy = v^2/2

Right!

Can you write y in terms of theta?


Miike012 said:
2.a = v^2/r

Yes.
You need to relate this to your forces.

Miike012 said:
3. SumFy = Ty - w = (m)(ay)
4. SumFx = Tx = (m)(ax)

Are these correct equations?

Yes, these are correct equations.

However, I suggest you try to find the forces aligned with the rope.
The tension is already aligned.
If you find the component of the weight aligned with the rope, you can find the resulting force along the rope.
The resulting force along the rope must match the centripetal acceleration.
 
Miike012 said:
"And if x and y are coordinates in (2), how did you relate them to a force of 1780 N."

I related 1780 to (x,y) by saying the end point of tension started at the origin, and because the motion is a circle I gave the following equation...
x^2 + y^2 = 1780^2... which relates it to x and y... would this not be correct?

Can it be that you intended Tx^2 + Ty^2 = 1780^2?

x and y would be coordinates that have "meter" as the unit.
1780 is the critical tensional forces that has "Newton" as the unit.

Tx and Ty would be the cartesian force components of the tensional force.
They also have "Newton" as the unit.
 
3. SumFx = T - wx = (m)(ax)
4. SumFy = -wy = (m)(ay)

like that?
 
Miike012 said:
3. SumFx = T - wx = (m)(ax)
4. SumFy = -wy = (m)(ay)

like that?

Yes.

Can you relate those quantities to the angle theta?
 
While I relate the equations the theta.. I was wondering, how come in some situations in circular motion sometimes the SumFy or SumFx has zero acceleration??
 
Miike012 said:
While I relate the equations the theta.. I was wondering, how come in some situations in circular motion sometimes the SumFy or SumFx has zero acceleration??

In circular motion the radial force is not zero, or it won't be circular motion.
The tangential force can be zero, and indeed is zero if we're talking about "uniform" circular motion.
 
Tan(theta) = wx/wy

cos(theta) = (...)/T
 
Last edited:
Here was my reasoning

Tx should be T
 
Attachments
  • Force diagram of a hanging weight: a horizontal ceiling bar with a vertical thin line down to a point, a red thick line from the bar to the point labeled Tx with angle Theta at the top, and a red vertical arrow labeled w below, with a triangle showing components wx, wy and angle Theta.
    tri.png
    4.2 KB · Views: 503
Right.

But I'm getting confused with what x and y stand for exactly.
So I'll use "radial" and "tangential" to keep things clear.

What I was looking for is:
wradial = w sin(θ)

And in your earlier equation for the conservation of energy:
g (L sin(θ)) = v^2/2

These need to be combined with:
Fradial = m acentripetal

Can you work that out?
 
T- (wy)Tan(theta = (m)(ax)
-(wx)Cot(theta) = (m)(ay)
 
Miike012 said:
F(radial) = m(2*g*L*(wradial/w))/r

How did you get that?
And what happened to the tensional force T?
 
im saying x and y because i labeled it with the following axis..
 
Attachments
  • Hand-drawn sketch of a black V-shaped path with endpoints labeled y and x, next to a red bent line segment with a dot and a small black dot.
    axis.png
    2.2 KB · Views: 497
Miike012 said:
im saying x and y because i labeled it with the following axis..

Ah, okay!
 
sin(θ) = wradial/w

g (L sin(θ)) = v^2/2
g(L*wradial/w) = v^2/2
v^2 = g(L*wradial/w)(2)

Fradial = m acentripetal = m(v^2/r)
Fradial = m (g(L*wradial/w)(2)/r)
 
And I am not sure what Fradial is
im guessing its the tension and wradial
 
Miike012 said:
And I am not sure what Fradial is
im guessing its the tension and wradial

Yes.

The total radial force Fradial = T - wradial.

Furthermore this force has to match the radial acceleration. So:
Fradial = m acentripetal

I you can rewrite this in only numbers and theta, you can solve for theta.
 
Miike012 said:
sin(θ) = wradial/w

g (L sin(θ)) = v^2/2
g(L*wradial/w) = v^2/2
v^2 = g(L*wradial/w)(2)

Fradial = m acentripetal = m(v^2/r)
Fradial = m (g(L*wradial/w)(2)/r)

Ah, okay.

Note that your r is the radius of the circular motion, which is equal to the length of the rope.
So r=L.

I'm afraid that eliminating theta does not help you forward though.
You should leave the sin(θ) in.

What you do need is that Fradial = T - wradial.
 
Thank you finally got it...
Sin(theta) = T/(m*g*2 + w)
 
How in the world did you piece everything together?? I was sitting here thinking I had to use the sum tan-gentle force equation...?
 
Miike012 said:
Thank you finally got it...
Sin(theta) = T/(m*g*2 + w)

Good!

But there's still something to be done...
What is the relation between m*g and w?


Miike012 said:
How in the world did you piece everything together?? I was sitting here thinking I had to use the sum tan-gentle force equation...?

Well, I guess there is a method to it.

First list all your data and relevant equations.

Then consider what the critical condition is.
In this case that the total radial force exceeds the critical threshold.
This will give you a formula.

And then use your data and relevant equations to find the unknown that is asked for.