How does polarity change periodically in charged rods connected to voltage source?

7 replies · 2K views · last reply
YMMMA
Messages
156
Reaction score
10

Homework Statement


In addition to the question given in the attached file below, I don’t understand how is the polarity changing periodically.

Homework Equations


Concept-based question, I guess.

The Attempt at a Solution


I have no idea how should I approach the question. So, if anyone has an idea, can he/she explain?
 
Attachments
  • Two diagrams of a voltage source connected to two vertical rods: left labelled Now, with plus signs on the upper rod and minus signs on the lower rod; right labelled Later, with the charges reversed. Below is a multiple-choice question.
    0D62014F-47E8-40E9-B5BE-67B2BED786B1.jpeg
    31.6 KB · Views: 359
A generator producing Alternating Current (AC) would be an example of such a voltage source. First one side is at higher voltage, then the other, and they switch back and forth in a sinusoidal pattern.

The question is asking you what the effect is of the charge distribution changing back and forth between those two pictures periodically. What have you learned about changing charge distributions?
 
*
YMMMA said:
In addition to the question given in the attached file below, I don’t understand how is the polarity changing periodically.
As mentioned by @RPinPA a signal generator can make such a changing output voltage. The voltage between the two rods could vary with a sinusoidal function like:

V(t) = 1V * sin (2π * 1kHz * t), and you could alter the amplitude from 1V and the frequency from 1kHz if you want a different driven waveform.
YMMMA said:
I have no idea how should I approach the question. So, if anyone has an idea, can he/she explain?
For each of the 2 figures, draw the E field lines from + to - charges, just as you do for other geometries with charge separation. If you need help with that, try Google Images with appropriate search terms to get some ideas. With those two modified diagrams, you can partially answer the question.

To fully answer the question, search on "dipole antenna operation" or similar. Let us know what you find... :smile:
 
RPinPA said:
A generator producing Alternating Current (AC) would be an example of such a voltage source. First one side is at higher voltage, then the other, and they switch back and forth in a sinusoidal pattern.

The question is asking you what the effect is of the charge distribution changing back and forth between those two pictures periodically. What have you learned about changing charge distributions?
Ahh, apparently I didn’t learn something about this topic. So, I need to know changing charge distribution and AC.
 
berkeman said:
*
As mentioned by @RPinPA a signal generator can make such a changing output voltage. The voltage between the two rods could vary with a sinusoidal function like:

V(t) = 1V * sin (2π * 1kHz * t), and you could alter the amplitude from 1V and the frequency from 1kHz if you want a different driven waveform.

For each of the 2 figures, draw the E field lines from + to - charges, just as you do for other geometries with charge separation. If you need help with that, try Google Images with appropriate search terms to get some ideas. With those two modified diagrams, you can partially answer the question.

To fully answer the question, search on "dipole antenna operation" or similar. Let us know what you find... :smile:

I don’t know a thing about the first part “
As mentioned by @RPinPA a signal generator can make such a changing output voltage. The voltage between the two rods could vary with a sinusoidal function like:

V(t) = 1V * sin (2π * 1kHz * t), and you could alter the amplitude from 1V and the frequency from 1kHz if you want a different driven waveform.“

But I do know how to draw electric fields. I am going to search more about the others ,and then come back to the question.
 
I have looked for dipole antenna and found that its like the ‘"rabbit ears" television antenna found on broadcast television sets’. There's a changing electric field throughout all the space because of the alternation and a changing electric field near the end of the rods. If the length is half a wavelength the will be radiation. So, I think the answer is D. Is my reasoning correct?
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of a half-wave dipole antenna receiving a radio wave, with green arrows for the electric field E, red bands for voltage V, black arrows for current, and a resistor R representing the receiver.
    005133AB-E1FF-4C64-BF02-4969D3AC8EFD.jpeg
    49.4 KB · Views: 363
YMMMA said:
So, I think the answer is D. Is my reasoning correct?
Yes, good work! :smile:
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: YMMMA
Many thanks!
berkeman said:
Yes, good work! :smile:
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: berkeman