Why does momentum conservation give v = V for a pulley collision?

2 replies · 2K views · last reply
cupid.callin
Messages
1,130
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement


Textbook problem diagram of a pulley with a block of mass m on the left and a pan of mass m on the right, with a small particle of mass m falling toward the pan, labelled v.



The Attempt at a Solution



Taking the pulley and strings, pan, ball, block as system ... momentum is conserved

therefore in Y direction(vertical) ...

-mv = -2mV + mV
-mv = -mV
v = V

which is incorrect (as i expected as there has to be some loss of velocity of particle in a collision)

How should i do it?
 
Attachments
  • Textbook problem figure: a block of mass m hangs on the left end of a string over a pulley, and a pan of mass m hangs on the right, with a particle of mass m falling toward the pan.
    Momentum (1).jpg
    29.1 KB · Views: 529
Try doing this using impulse:
Let the time of collision be dt and force be F.
Use F.dt = change in momentum for all the 3 bodies, then find the final velocity.
 
ashishsinghal said:
Try doing this using impulse:
Let the time of collision be dt and force be F.
Use F.dt = change in momentum for all the 3 bodies, then find the final velocity.

WARNING: This method by me is a general method of solving collision questions. This is not to be used blindly in this case. Consider the forces which brings the change in momentum.