Is the Mass of Earth Determined by Henry Cavendish's Method?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Mr.Socrates
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Earth Mass
AI Thread Summary
The mass of the Earth is approximately 6 x 10^24 kg, and the mass of all humans combined is negligible in comparison, totaling about 5 x 10^11 kg, which is virtually zero percent of Earth's mass. Any mass gained by humans comes from Earth itself, meaning the total mass of the planet remains unchanged despite human population growth. The discussion highlights misconceptions about the relationship between human mass and Earth's mass, emphasizing that human bodies are made from Earth's materials. Additionally, the historical method used by Henry Cavendish to determine Earth's mass is acknowledged as impressive and insightful. Overall, the Earth's mass is immense, and the contribution of human mass is insignificant.
Mr.Socrates
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
All Of Us Know Most Of The Constants In Physics Have A Constant Mass Of Earth Used...

Is It True That Mass Of Earth The Same Or Approximately The Same ...

My Prediction Is It Will Be Twice The Mass Calculated And All The Nearby Quantities Will Be 1/2 The Orginal Value...

The Reason Y I Say This Very Simple ... Assume The Mass Of Earth Is X Billion Kilos... The No Of Humans In Earth Be X Billion... Let The Mass Of A Human Be The Least 1 Kg Then The Mass Of Earth Is = Mass Of Earth + Mass Of Human Beings.

If U Start To Reply As Approximation ... The Word Approximately Means It Should Be Any Were Near By...
Not The Difference This Big...
 
Earth sciences news on Phys.org
So some how, as I gain weight, that weight was not part of the Earth's mass before I gained it... Tell me where did it come from? Mars? The Moon?

The mass of the inhabitants of the Earth do not change the mass of the earth. All of the matter which is incorporated into your body as you grow was part of, and always will be part of the Earth's mass. Unless of course you die in deep space.
 
A couple of misconceptions.

As Integral mentioned, any mass in the human body came from the planet Earth, so there is no net change due to the number of humans.

The mass of the Earth is 6 x 10^24. There are about 6.6 billion humans with an average mass of about 75 kg. This totals up to about 5 x 10^11 kg. To find the percentage of the Earth's mass that is made up of humans, just divide the total human mass by the Earth's mass and multiply by 100. It's virtually zero.
 
BobG said:
To find the percentage of the Earth's mass that is made up of humans, just divide the total human mass by the Earth's mass and multiply by 100. It's virtually zero.
I think we're overpopulating.

Anybody ever drive through Oklahoma? Or the midwest? EMPTY, GOOD land. NO BODY there.
 
Although it makes you wonder...is the total mass of the Earth increasing or decreasing (since the planet absorbs energy from the sun and reradiates some into space). I wonder what the net loss/gain is?
 
Mr.Socrates said:
All Of Us Know Most Of The Constants In Physics Have A Constant Mass Of Earth Used...
Is It True That Mass Of Earth The Same Or Approximately The Same ...
My Prediction Is It Will Be Twice The Mass Calculated And All The Nearby Quantities Will Be 1/2 The Orginal Value...
The Reason Y I Say This Very Simple ... Assume The Mass Of Earth Is X Billion Kilos... The No Of Humans In Earth Be X Billion... Let The Mass Of A Human Be The Least 1 Kg Then The Mass Of Earth Is = Mass Of Earth + Mass Of Human Beings.
If U Start To Reply As Approximation ... The Word Approximately Means It Should Be Any Were Near By...
Not The Difference This Big...

Mass of Earth is X billion kilos, sure, if "X" = 6,000,000,000,000,000.
 
BobG said:
A couple of misconceptions.
As Integral mentioned, any mass in the human body came from the planet Earth, so there is no net change due to the number of humans.
The mass of the Earth is 6 x 10^24. There are about 6.6 billion humans with an average mass of about 75 kg. This totals up to about 5 x 10^11 kg. To find the percentage of the Earth's mass that is made up of humans, just divide the total human mass by the Earth's mass and multiply by 100. It's virtually zero.
To put it in even more perspective:
Even if you imagined that the whole Earth, oceans included, was covered with people at a population density equal to that of Tokyo, the total mass of humanity would still only be about 2x10^{16} kg. Compare that to the mass of the Earth, 6x10^{24} kg ,and the mass of the people would still only be 0.000000328% that of the Earth.
 
The following conclusion seems warranted:
The Earth is big, really, really
BIG!
 
arildno said:
The following conclusion seems warranted:
The Earth is big, really, really
BIG!

I've seen bigger... :-p
 
  • #10
I have just read the extremely interesting story of how the mass of the Earth was first determined in 1798 by Henry Cavendish, and I must say I am extremely impressed. It would not have occurred to me to figure it out this way, or any way, in a thousand years.
 
Back
Top