Why Is Kerry a Stronger Choice Than Bush on Key Issues?

  • Context: News 
  • Thread starter Thread starter member 5645
  • Start date Start date
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion centers around the comparative strengths of John Kerry versus George W. Bush on various political issues, including Iraq, the economy, healthcare, domestic social structure, terrorism, military, government spending, and immigration. Participants express their views on Kerry's qualifications and policies while seeking to understand the rationale behind supporting him over Bush.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Exploratory
  • Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants express a desire to understand Kerry's positives without engaging in negative rhetoric about Bush.
  • One participant suggests that Kerry's appeal is primarily that he is not Bush, indicating a lack of specific policy enthusiasm.
  • Another participant critiques Kerry for being indecisive or inconsistent on issues, implying a lack of clear stance.
  • There are humorous critiques of Kerry's wealth and lifestyle, juxtaposed with claims of his relatability and environmentalism.
  • Some participants highlight Kerry's military service and charitable contributions as positive traits, albeit with sarcasm regarding their significance.
  • One participant emphasizes the need for voters to research issues independently, expressing concern over the implications of Bush's continued presidency on social and environmental policies.
  • Another participant outlines specific policy proposals attributed to Kerry, including tax reforms and healthcare initiatives aimed at children and the middle class.
  • Some argue that Kerry's defense policies prioritize troop efficiency over expensive weapon systems, countering Republican narratives about his voting record.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally do not reach a consensus on Kerry's strengths or weaknesses. Multiple competing views remain, with some expressing skepticism about Kerry's effectiveness and others advocating for his policies as preferable to Bush's.

Contextual Notes

Participants express varying levels of knowledge about Kerry's policies, and some points raised are based on personal anecdotes or humor rather than detailed policy analysis. There is a notable absence of agreement on what specific expectations voters have for Kerry.

member 5645
Seriously. This isn't flamebait, and I am going to read it with an open mind.

Hitting the larger topics (and adding any you wish), let me (and others) know why Kerry is really a better pick than Bush. And this means NO RAMBLING RHETORIC of Bush Bashing. I'm curious as to Kerry's positives over Bush, not why Bush is so evil.

Iraq, economy, healthcare, domestic social structure, terrorism, military, government spending, illegal aliens,etc.

I am more than able to read Kerry's campaign website, but I want to know what the average Kerry voter is expecting of him on these issues.
I'm trying to stomach Kerry in a manner to look at the election with an open mind up until November. I don't want to make a hardpressed decision until election day, in order to keep my eyes open on the issues :smile:
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Why Kerry? He's not Bush.
 
Kerry stands for both sides of every issue. What more could you ask for?
 
Although Kerry has a net worth of $700,000,000.00, he is just an average guy like us. That is because he knows just exactly how tough we have it. He knows how expensive it is to run our fleets of SUVs with the price of gas being so high. He knows how difficult it is for us to afford the fuel for our private Gulfstream 5 jets. He knows how we feel when we fill up the fuel tanks on our huge yachts. He can see how we feel about the rich running our country, instead of average joes like him.

He is an enviromentalist. He once even turned down the thermostat at one of his mansions for 15 minutes just to help save our planet. Even though he burns thousands of gallons of fuel oil each year to heat his mansions, he did make this one attempt to make a difference.

He cares about minorities. He even actually spoke to a black man once. A black friend of mine met Mr. Kerry once in a grocery store. It was so nice of Mr. Kerry to take the time to stop and talk to him. As Mr. Kerry stepped in front of him in line he actually spoke to him and the cashier. As he rushed past and cut in line he said "Do you know who I am?" Now isn't that nice. Not everyone would do that.

He is also a highly decorated war hero too. I suffered several paper cuts and a sore finger myself while in the service and I'm still waiting for my purple hearts. Maybe if I were better connected it would help.

Mr. Kerry also has a long record of charitable contributions, he regularly donates as much as $100 a year to charity. He doesn't do this just for the tax break, he really cares about people.

I didn't vote for him in the primary, but I'll vote for him in the general election. That way I can say that I voted against him before I voted for him. Yup, he's the guy for me.
 
Adam said:
Why Kerry? He's not Bush.

Since you are an Australian, your vote will only be counted by Florida democrats, twice.
 
Adam said:
Why Kerry? He's not Bush.

See, this is the same rhetoric I'm talking about.
I personally don't like the guy's persona. However, I'm trying to not go the next six months with my mind made up, in case my bias would then lead me to make a candidate out to be better than they are.
However, even TRYING to like Kerry and put him at some sort of neutral ground seems impossible since no one seems to really know what they are expecting him to do...except not be Bush.
 
hughes johnson said:
Although Kerry has a net worth of $700,000,000.00, he is just an average guy like us. That is because he knows just exactly how tough we have it. He knows how expensive it is to run our fleets of SUVs with the price of gas being so high. He knows how difficult it is for us to afford the fuel for our private Gulfstream 5 jets. He knows how we feel when we fill up the fuel tanks on our huge yachts. He can see how we feel about the rich running our country, instead of average joes like him.

He is an enviromentalist. He once even turned down the thermostat at one of his mansions for 15 minutes just to help save our planet. Even though he burns thousands of gallons of fuel oil each year to heat his mansions, he did make this one attempt to make a difference.

He cares about minorities. He even actually spoke to a black man once. A black friend of mine met Mr. Kerry once in a grocery store. It was so nice of Mr. Kerry to take the time to stop and talk to him. As Mr. Kerry stepped in front of him in line he actually spoke to him and the cashier. As he rushed past and cut in line he said "Do you know who I am?" Now isn't that nice. Not everyone would do that.

He is also a highly decorated war hero too. I suffered several paper cuts and a sore finger myself while in the service and I'm still waiting for my purple hearts. Maybe if I were better connected it would help.

Mr. Kerry also has a long record of charitable contributions, he regularly donates as much as $100 a year to charity. He doesn't do this just for the tax break, he really cares about people.

I didn't vote for him in the primary, but I'll vote for him in the general election. That way I can say that I voted against him before I voted for him. Yup, he's the guy for me.


If nothing else, this cracked me up :cool:
 
phatmonky said:
If nothing else, this cracked me up :cool:

I'm not even a pro. If this wack gets elected Jay Leno's monologue will be even funnier than it was during the Clinton administration.
 
Im not sure it really matters who you vote for. No matter what happens, it's always some goofball in a cheap suit screwing the country up. Who was the last President who really stood out? Don't worry, the above criteria is for politicians worldwide. The last Prime Minister to make a difference here in England was Maggie Thatcher. And that's cos she wore cheap dresses. (actually i thought Maggie did a great job!)
 
  • #10
YOU must research the issues and decide for yourself- JK campaign will not tell you what to think. One thing is certain for me in any case, there is real grave danger for this country if Bush remains in power. Look at Texas for a moment--in a state that voted FDR a landslide, environmental and social structures which were designed to protect the public are destroyed; public institutions are replaced with private enterprises with political connections. It's an old formula- socialize the cost, privatize the profits, and it leaves the NASCAR dads & moms hurting big time.
Iraq, economy, healthcare, domestic social structure, terrorism, military, government spending, illegal aliens,etc.
You left one thing out-- it's a pretty big one. Seeing how it's "Earth Day" !
Okay, since you asked and I know a little about some of this, I'll try: On Iraq, the position is that the President needs to make an effort to garner real support to the tune of 200,000 to 400,000 NATO troops & UN peacekeepers immediately. This is something GWB's crew has been assiduously avoiding.
On the economy, there would be a corporate tax cut for 99% of US companies that don't ship their jobs overseas. The Kennedy era loopholes that allow them to ship overseas would be closed. There would be a further tax cut for 98% of the middle class, while the tax cut for >>individuals<< making over 200,000 per year would be repealed to balance the budget.

Okay, still with me? On healthcare there is talk of providing public care for 100% of little kids, and some kind of structure for adults although I'm not up on all details of this part.

On terrorism, JK would put resources into actually fighting terrorism instead of busting kids for weed.
 
  • #11
Reasons to vote Kerry

1. Sensible economic policy - John Kerry does not believe anyone action is a cure-all for any economic problem.
2. Smart on defense - Kerry has been advocating for years against big, boondoggle weapons systems in favor of troop efficiency. Republicans have been hyping Kerry's voting record on big defense systems, but the truth is, all the systems he voted against have been wasteful, taking money away from things that could really help soldiers.
3. Smart on Intelligence - Kerry advocated the cutting of spending on the NRO (satellite based intelligence) in lieu of cutting human intelligence.
4. Integrity - He is an honest man who fights for his principles. He is not afraid to take a stand against his party, or against popular opinion.
5. Mentally equipped for the job - He is not afraid to advocate complex solutions to complicated problems even though this does not make for good sound-bites.
6. Diplomatic - He does not pointlessly antagonize foreign governments or peoples.
7. Professional - Despite being one of the more left-leaning Democrats early in his career, he was always on decent terms with his Republican colleagues.
8. A decorated veteran - While he could have easily avoided service, he served in Vietnam earning a Silver Star, Bronze Star and 3 Purple Hearts. While it may not mean much to many people, it is a good time to have a president who can speak to our soldiers without hypocrisy.
9. Responsibility - If Kerry is elected, we will really know who is in charge.

Njorl
 
  • #12
Adam said:
Why Kerry? He's not Bush.
I've heard that before and its logical, but I won't vote for someone because they aren't someone else. It just feels wrong to me. I will vote for someone I like. Period. And if that means writing in Howard Stern (I might), I will do it.
 
  • #13
Njorl said:
Reasons to vote Kerry
Integrity - He is an honest man who fights for his principles.

A decorated veteran - While he could have easily avoided service, he served in Vietnam earning a Silver Star, Bronze Star and 3 Purple Hearts.

He is anything but honest. He has gotten caught in more lies in 8 months than the legendary liar Bill Clinton told in 8 years.

I'd be a decorated veteran too if I could recommend myself for my own medals for paper cuts, and I had political connections like Tip O'Neil and Ted Kennedy. He didn't even finish his tour of duty like the poor and middle class soldiers did, he went home early. This is not "fighting for his principles" this is fighting to save his own ***, and riding on the backs of the poor and the middle class. The profits he makes from us go to pay for his fuel guzzling gulfstream 5 jet, his yacht, his mansions, and his fleet of SUVs. This is the rich living off of the sweat and blood of the poor by telling us that he is on our side, and we believe him! What a crock.
 
  • #14
Njorl has given reasons perhaps, but not facts.
1. Sensible economic policy - John Kerry does not believe anyone action is a cure-all for any economic problem.
I’m not aware of a Kerry economic policy. He has stated that he supports Bush’s tax policy except for the “the wealthy American” bit. If he does have a policy, he should submit it to the GAO to test its merit as compared to the president’s policy. The Commerce Department has released its findings re. The economy. It found the economy was in a sharp decline during the last year of the Clinton Administration and reached bottom during the 2nd quarter of the Bush administration while the government was still using the Clinton budget. When Bush announced his tax cut plans, a rebound occurred and, due to the cut, continues to this day. In fact the growth in 2003 was greater than at any point during the Clinton years.
2. Smart on defense - Kerry has been advocating for years against big, boondoggle weapons systems in favor of troop efficiency. Republicans have been hyping Kerry's voting record on big defense systems, but the truth is, all the systems he voted against have been wasteful, taking money away from things that could really help soldiers.
One problem a long serving senator has is that votes cast many years ago are not always relevant to present and may be attacked by an opponent. For that reason I cannot hold Kerry responsible to defense cutting in the ‘80’s. The more responsible question would be to ask what he has done to improve our countries defenses. Asked that way he has failed miserably.
3. Smart on Intelligence - Kerry advocated the cutting of spending on the NRO (satellite based intelligence) in lieu of cutting human intelligence.
The truth, if one ignores the outrageous support Kerry provided to Clinton’s “criminal vs. terrorist” intelligence barrier is: Kerry introduced a bill on Sept. 29, 1995—S. 1290. The bill sought to cut the intelligence budget by $1.5 billion over a five-year period. Described by Kerry bashers as “gutting” I would personally only consider it an example of stupidity.
4. Integrity - He is an honest man who fights for his principles. He is not afraid to take a stand against his party, or against popular opinion.
On the contrary, he has proven to bend with the wind. As Howard Dean’s rants re: Bush caused him to be the front runner, Kerry responded in kind and drew away from his more subdued comments. He, like Gore, assumes acting rolls, such as the use of “four letter words” when addressing motorcyclists. I’m sure I need not remind you of the “I voted for it and against it” blather. Quote is not precise.
5. Mentally equipped for the job - He is not afraid to advocate complex solutions to complicated problems even though this does not make for good sound-bites.
Very true, I’m sure can provide the most complex solutions we’ve ever endured. One can expect social plans similar to the laughably complex health care plan produced by Hillary Clinton. When has complexity ever been considered advantageous?
6. Diplomatic - He does not pointlessly antagonize foreign governments or peoples.
When nations and the UN act against the best interests of the US and gain financially by criminal activities in doing so, those nations and organizations should be antagonized to the greatest extant possible. Pointless or deserved?
7. Professional - Despite being one of the more left-leaning Democrats early in his career, he was always on decent terms with his Republican colleagues.
Let us be a little more up to date. The National Journal, a non-ideological, authoritative weekly magazine found Kerry in 2003 to inhabit the far-left fringe.
8. A decorated veteran - While he could have easily avoided service, he served in Vietnam earning a Silver Star, Bronze Star and 3 Purple Hearts. While it may not mean much to many people, it is a good time to have a president who can speak to our soldiers without hypocrisy.
Until recently I would not differ with that statement, but it seems all is not yet known. Never the less his service is to be admired. It seems it has unfortunately left him mentally scarred and perhaps not able to make the responsible decisions.
9. Responsibility - If Kerry is elected, we will really know who is in charge.
Does anyone doubt that Bush’s policies are his, that the people around him submit to his wishes? Fortunately we’ll never know that about Kerry.
 
  • #15
lol Google knows about Kerry...take a PEAK
 
  • #16
I'm sure there's no shortage of ketchup in the Kerry household.
 
  • #17
hughes johnson said:
Although Kerry has a net worth of $700,000,000.00, he is just an average guy like us. That is because he knows just exactly how tough we have it. He knows how expensive it is to run our fleets of SUVs with the price of gas being so high. He knows how difficult it is for us to afford the fuel for our private Gulfstream 5 jets. He knows how we feel when we fill up the fuel tanks on our huge yachts. He can see how we feel about the rich running our country, instead of average joes like him.

He is an enviromentalist. He once even turned down the thermostat at one of his mansions for 15 minutes just to help save our planet. Even though he burns thousands of gallons of fuel oil each year to heat his mansions, he did make this one attempt to make a difference.

He cares about minorities. He even actually spoke to a black man once. A black friend of mine met Mr. Kerry once in a grocery store. It was so nice of Mr. Kerry to take the time to stop and talk to him. As Mr. Kerry stepped in front of him in line he actually spoke to him and the cashier. As he rushed past and cut in line he said "Do you know who I am?" Now isn't that nice. Not everyone would do that.

He is also a highly decorated war hero too. I suffered several paper cuts and a sore finger myself while in the service and I'm still waiting for my purple hearts. Maybe if I were better connected it would help.

Mr. Kerry also has a long record of charitable contributions, he regularly donates as much as $100 a year to charity. He doesn't do this just for the tax break, he really cares about people.

I didn't vote for him in the primary, but I'll vote for him in the general election. That way I can say that I voted against him before I voted for him. Yup, he's the guy for me.


So let's compare this to Bush, shall we?

Yes, John Kerry's rich. Actually, he married into it, his wife is the one with the money, but that's beside the point.

Bush is rich too. Who's more rich? I don't know, I suspect Bush. Of course Bush is a regular guy. He was born rich. His whole family's rich. Because his dad works for a defense contractor, and Bush started a war based on lies, he's going to be inheriting a bunch more money now too.

Environment? Who's better on the environment? Really? Well, Bush promised on the campaign trail that he would cut CO2 emissions. Of course he broke that campaign promise among others. Drilling in ANWAR, cut down the forests to protect them from fire, Governor of NJ as head of the EPA and had to leave in disgrace. So it's rather obvious that Kerry is better then Bush on the environment. Although I admit that's not saying much.

Minorities? All right. Let's talk about minorities. What do minorities have to say about Kerry vs. Bush. Well, ninety percent of blacks voted against Bush in 2001. I'm sure when Bush went to a white supremacist camp and talked about "taking back america" that didn't help their views. And then there's the muslims, which I expect will be voting for Kerry. And homosexuals. Bush has sure gone after the immigrant vote, but that didn't make his base very happy. So I guess if you care about minorities you'll be voting for Kerry. The bigotted white male vote will be going to Bush. Again.

War hero? Absolutely. Silver star. Bronze star. Couple of purple hearts. He took a lot of shrapnel in vietnam. And if you don't think he deserved the medals then you're being disrespectful to the troops. But I"m sure nobody hear would do that. Bush, of course, used his connections to dodge the draft. Apparently he was AWOL for most of his stint in the TANG. It's known he was grounded from flying, when he didn't show up for his medical. The logical assumption being he wouldn't pass his drug exam.

Charitable contributions? That I don't know much about. Bush has made lots of charitable contributions. Take Enron for example. Ken Lay, who Bush says he never met, got his own desk in the White House. And then there's Halliburton. You know, Cheney's old employer. They got billions of Iraq money and still didn't have to feed the troops.
 
  • #18
hughes johnson said:
He is anything but honest. He has gotten caught in more lies in 8 months than the legendary liar Bill Clinton told in 8 years.

I'd be a decorated veteran too if I could recommend myself for my own medals for paper cuts, and I had political connections like Tip O'Neil and Ted Kennedy. He didn't even finish his tour of duty like the poor and middle class soldiers did, he went home early. This is not "fighting for his principles" this is fighting to save his own ***, and riding on the backs of the poor and the middle class. The profits he makes from us go to pay for his fuel guzzling gulfstream 5 jet, his yacht, his mansions, and his fleet of SUVs. This is the rich living off of the sweat and blood of the poor by telling us that he is on our side, and we believe him! What a crock.


Bill Clinton lied about sex. Bush lied about a war that's killed more civilians then Osama bin Laden. What did Kerry lie about?

As for Kerry's service. He took shrapnel in the buttock and his arm. And that was his third purple heart. Where were you wounded in Vietnam? In fact, what service were you in?

Oh, and yes, he was sent home after three months of his tour. Of course that was when he was on his second tour. He completed the entire year of his first tour, so volunteering for the second was above and beyond the call of duty. And was much more then the chickenhawk republicans did.
 
Last edited:
  • #19
Chemicalsuperfreak said:
Bill Clinton lied about sex.
I didn't realize that Clinton lied about sex TOO!


Bush lied about a war that's killed more civilians then Osama bin Laden.
You seem to like this bin Laden guy, maybe you should vote for him.

What did Kerry lie about?
You do read the newspapers don't you? What DIDN'T he lie about? Mr. Kerry is not your ordinary liar, he seems to enjoy it. He acts as if lying were an olympic event, and Sen. Kennedy is handing out the gold medals again.

Where were you wounded in Vietnam?
I'm not going to brag about my military service in Vietnam on this forum.

Oh, and yes, he was sent home after three months of his tour. Of course that was when he was on his second tour. He completed the entire year of his first tour, so volunteering for the second was above and beyond the call of duty. And was much more then the chickenhawk republicans did.

Many republicans served in Vietnam without complaining, even though it was the democrats who started the war (again). Many came home in body bags. They didn't have the option to ditty when the going got tough, like Mr. Kerry did, and they didn't come home and whine about it either.
 
Last edited:
  • #20
hughes johnson said:
You do read the newspapers don't you? What DIDN'T he lie about? Mr. Kerry is not your ordinary liar, he seems to enjoy it.

I really don't read the papers. Can you give some examples?
 
  • #21
The "lies" Kerry has told usually turn out to have been the truth, and it is the RNC and its operatives who are actually lying. For instance, some of the "tax raises" that Kerry supposedly voted for were actually tax cuts. More lying from the White House, of course.
 
  • #22
Is it really that impossible to stick to the positives of Kerry? To show the actual things that will change for the better if he is elected. A little comare and contrasting between the candidates is all good - but you guys are already turning this into the usual ****fest that so many other threads have turned to.

For those that have offered as unopinionated factual information as you can, thank you thus far.
 
  • #23
Adam said:
Why Kerry? He's not Bush.

Here's where your nice thread got derailed. Your intial post shows that it was expected.
 
Last edited:
  • #24
phatmonky said:
Is it really that impossible to stick to the positives of Kerry? To show the actual things that will change for the better if he is elected. A little comare and contrasting between the candidates is all good - but you guys are already turning this into the usual ****fest that so many other threads have turned to.

For those that have offered as unopinionated factual information as you can, thank you thus far.
Even if 60% of the American people voted for JK, Kerry might not win because the electronic voting machines are going to be used to count 30% of the votes and are provably fraudulent, so why bother debating?
 
  • #25
What are these voting machines? Would you elaborate a bit?
 
  • #26
ShawnD said:
I really don't read the papers. Can you give some examples?

Just search john kerrys lies. There's enough information to keep you busy until the election.
 
  • #27
schwarzchildradius said:
Even if 60% of the American people voted for JK, Kerry might not win because the electronic voting machines are going to be used to count 30% of the votes and are provably fraudulent, so why bother debating?

Really? Prove it.
 
  • #28
schwarzchildradius said:
Even if 60% of the American people voted for JK, Kerry might not win because the electronic voting machines are going to be used to count 30% of the votes and are provably fraudulent, so why bother debating?


Eesssh, more of this assumptive negative logic. I just can't fathom going through life with such a bleak outlook everyday!
https://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=22121
 
  • #29
hughes johnson said:
Just search john kerrys lies. There's enough information to keep you busy until the election.

I did a google of "John Kerry" and "lies".

I found a lot of sites that do a lot of claiming that he is a liar, but none of them cite any actual lies. I also found sites with stories of lies told about Kerry. Those actually document their cases.

I was never very enthusiastic about him, but now, that Hughes has pushed me, I'm beginning to think Kerry may be one of the most honest politicians ever. Thanks Hughes. All politicians lie, but I just can't seem to find any of Kerry's. Anybody want to help?

Njorl
 
  • #30
Njorl said:
I did a google of "John Kerry" and "lies".

I found a lot of sites that do a lot of claiming that he is a liar, but none of them cite any actual lies. I also found sites with stories of lies told about Kerry. Those actually document their cases.

I was never very enthusiastic about him, but now, that Hughes has pushed me, I'm beginning to think Kerry may be one of the most honest politicians ever. Thanks Hughes. All politicians lie, but I just can't seem to find any of Kerry's. Anybody want to help?

Njorl

I"d like some answers too, only I'd like the answers to why he hedged questions about Al Hubbard and sat beside the man on Capitol hill knowing he had never served in Vietnam. Why he waited til a staged event on capitol hill to come forth about the atrocities he said he had witnessed in vietnam, what was his involvement regarding these atrocities he witnessed and why didn't he report them at the time? I want to know why he lied about having left VVAW before the meeting in which they voted on the senate assassinations, and then later hedged and said he quit that day? yet later was still speaking for them? Did he report this meeting to the FBI or any other officials? What was Kerry's responsibility in regards to the POW's left behind and the deals made with the N. Viet cong?

Any of the Kerry supporters have the answers to these questions? Seriously, no rhetoric involved. I want to know.
 

Similar threads

Replies
23
Views
4K
Replies
22
Views
4K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
4K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
3K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
5K
  • · Replies 20 ·
Replies
20
Views
4K
  • · Replies 45 ·
2
Replies
45
Views
6K
  • · Replies 40 ·
2
Replies
40
Views
10K
  • · Replies 68 ·
3
Replies
68
Views
14K
  • · Replies 27 ·
Replies
27
Views
6K