PDA

View Full Version : An Adequate Proof?


zeronem
Aug1-04, 03:27 AM
This seems like a very easy problem, but I just wanted to know if my proof is valid for it. It is very simple,

Show that the differential equation |\frac {dy}{dx}| +|y| + 1 = 0 has no solutions.

Well simply this, |\frac {dy}{dx}| + |y| = -1

The sum of Two Absolute values can never be a negative. Therefore there is no solution for the equation

|\frac {dy}{dx}| +|y| + 1 = 0

Is this valid? Or do I need more precise wording?

TenaliRaman
Aug1-04, 04:25 AM
looks good to me! (unless i am overseeing something).

HallsofIvy
Aug1-04, 10:33 AM
Yes, that's perfectly valid. You could also note that
|\frac {dy}{dx}| +|y| + 1 cannot be less than 1 and so can never be equal to 0. Although it is not necessary to state it explicitely you should be aware that you are really talking about the value for each x.