PDA

View Full Version : Difference between BCC and SC


u_know_who
Oct4-11, 10:05 AM
Hello, while studying crystalline solid structure one thing i don't understand. What does the "basis" means. Lattice seems clear but the basis comes along with problem. The problem arise in this case :

CsCl structure is not BCC (Body Centered Cubic). It is SC (Simple Cubic) with two basis.

That what says in the book.

My question is, if i consider CsCl is not BCC and it can be represented by SC with two basis (CS+ and Cl-) then why can't we imagine or consider original BCC structure as a combination of SC with two basis (two Fe atoms). But it is clearly declared that BCC is an unique Bravis lattice.

Can anyone clear me out?

DrDu
Oct4-11, 10:25 AM
Because the iron atoms are symmetry equivalent with respect to translations while a Cs and a Cl atom are clearly not. The same holds already in molecular physics Fe_2 molecule has symmetry group \text{D}_{\infty h} while CsCl has only \text{C}_{\infty v}.

Useful nucleus
Oct8-11, 07:16 PM
There is nothing wrong at all in considering BCC as simple cubic with two atoms as a basis. Similarly, FCC is a simple cubic with four atoms as a basis.

However, CsCl CANNOT be BCC because BCC sites are not occupied by the same species.

Chapter 4 in Solid State Physics by Ashcroft and Mermin gives a crystal clear explanation for these details.

DrDu
Oct9-11, 03:28 AM
There is nothing wrong at all in considering BCC as simple cubic with two atoms as a basis. Similarly, FCC is a simple cubic with four atoms as a basis.

However, CsCl CANNOT be BCC because BCC sites are not occupied by the same species.

Chapter 4 in Solid State Physics by Ashcroft and Mermin gives a crystal clear explanation for these details.
Yes, but you are considering then only a sub-group of the full crystallographic group and thus loose information.

Useful nucleus
Oct9-11, 08:40 PM
Can you elaborate more on this, please?

xiyangxixia
Oct9-11, 10:50 PM
The crystal must at least two basis if they are SCC. Similarly, FCC at least four basis.

DrDu
Oct10-11, 02:10 AM
If you treat e.g. iron using an enlarged unit cell, you resign to make use of the fact that the two iron atoms in your basis are symmetry equivalent.