View Single Post
jdg812
#14
Jan13-08, 11:53 AM
P: 91
Quote Quote by DaveC426913 View Post
But I don't think the whole volume participates at that point. Due to inertia and friction I imagine you can consider the dynamics of a smaller volume of only a few gallons surrounding the drain.
Consider only FIVE gallons of water surrounding the drain.
At t = 0 (or t = 10 sec), the funnel spins slowly.

At t = 1 min, the first five gallons are gone. There are another five gallons of water surrounding the drain. The funnel spins quickly. Why behavior of the next five gallons, which forms quickly spinning funnel is different from behavior of the first five gallons, which formed slowly spinning funnel?