View Single Post
marcus
marcus is online now
#11
Nov19-11, 01:50 AM
Astronomy
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
marcus's Avatar
P: 22,794
Quote Quote by tom.stoer View Post
Let's not restart the discussion here, but ...

... the recent reformulation does not solve many old issues!
But how do we know that? I have not seen any critical analysis of 1102.3660 which lays out the issues which are not resolved. Except of course the reservations freely stated by the author himself right in the paper.

In particular Alex'ov and Roche paper does not seem relevant. I don't believe I have expressed my misgivings about it. It does not even seem honestly objective to me.