I am serious and you havent addressed the question. In a mind experiment, if I could stand off some distance from the universe I could point and say...'there it is' and there would be some central area to that thing. Or, using a different approach....since everything in the universe blasted from the singularity it is obvious that the parts of the universe, including space itself is accelerating outward from that initial start. If it isnt then from what are all the elements of the universe accellerating? IF we could play the tape backward we could easily pinpoint the location of the origination point. Just because we cant, or have difficulty figuring out how to locate the point doesnt mean it doesnt exist. And since it DID once exist...that being the point of the big bang...by what logic do you determine that it immediately is lost and cant be found?

It seems that everything is accelerating from somewhere common otherwise everything would be accelerating from different origins. Just because everything seems to be accelerating from our vantage point only means we cant tell where the origin is. That does not mean it doesnt exist.

Unless you are willing to argue that every body is accelerating from different origins then they must be sharing a common origin. Where?

tex