View Single Post
Michael C
#38
Mar2-12, 04:16 PM
P: 132
Quote Quote by Michael C View Post
Adel, I'm going to stick to the train frame and give some names to things so we can be clear about what we are discussing:

IN THE TRAIN FRAME
A and B are the two ends of the train.
C is the point somewhere between them where there is a light source.
p is the event "a light signal is emitted at C".
q is the event "the light signal from C reaches A".
r is the event "the light signal from C reaches B".

What you seem to be claiming is that it could be possible to send a light signal from A after event q that will reach B before event r. Am I correct?
Quote Quote by Adel Makram View Post
yes correct
Without using any relativistic calculations it's easy enough to see that this is impossible. Just put a mirror at A.

But you seem to be claiming that relativistic calculations show this to be possible. In order to understand your argument I need more explanation. In the PDF you just attached, what exactly do you mean by t`a and AB` ? In what frame of reference are you doing your calculations?