Register to reply

Rutherford's experiment

by benzun_1999
Tags: experiment, rutherford
Share this thread:
Sep28-03, 07:35 AM
P: 258
Dear reader,
Did the alpha particles hit the electrons during the alpha particle bombardment? if so where did they go?

Phys.Org News Partner Physics news on
Technique simplifies the creation of high-tech crystals
Working group explores the 'frustration' of spin glasses
New analysis of oxide glass structures could guide the forecasting of melt formation in planetary interiors
Sep28-03, 04:24 PM
FZ+'s Avatar
P: 1,954
Er hmm... Rutherford's experiment referred to the deflection of alpha particles, not their absorption. Their detector lacked the sophistication to working out anything to do with that.

alpha - electron interactions? One would expect the alpha particle to simply ionise the particle, and become a helium atom. As far as I know, of course.
jimmy p
Sep28-03, 05:09 PM
PF Gold
jimmy p's Avatar
P: 580
Are you referring to Rutherford's famous experiment, the one where he fired alpha particles at a thin sheet of gold, expecting them to go through the sheet which a majority of did but some reflected off or were deflected at odd angles??? if so then....

The alpha particles that were almost completely reflected hit the nuclei of an atom. An atom's nuclei is massive (full of mass) but compared to at entire atoms radius they are tiny which is why so few were reflected. This is why Rutherford was quoted 'It's like firing a shell at a sheet of paper, and the shell bouncing back' It was that suprising to him because before that he had accepted the traditional 'Plum Puddiing' assumption of atomic structure.

The alpha particles that were deflected off and less obtuse angles where, so did not follow the beam, were repelled by the charge of the nucleus of the gold atoms. The electrons had very little-no deciding factor in the path of the alpha particles.

Im not sure if this has helped answer your question or if you wanted a more detailed answer but oh well, this is the best i can give!!!!

Sep29-03, 11:37 AM
P: 258
Rutherford's experiment

Yes i am talking about the experiment you mentioned but im not clear adout the answer you gave. i feel that the alpha particels must have not hit the electrons as electrons were not there due to the reason that they were waves then. as per my hypothesis electronsonly act as particles when an another wave interacts with it.

The more the dimentions we know, more we know.
Sep29-03, 02:54 PM
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
chroot's Avatar
P: 10,429
Um yeah..... riiiiiiight.... theory development, anyone?

- Warren
Sep29-03, 03:59 PM
Integral's Avatar
P: 7,315
The electrons are simply to small to effect the passage of an alpha particle. How much is the path of your car effected when a bug splats on the windshield?
Sep29-03, 04:13 PM
Sci Advisor
P: 875
Well, next year is the return of the 17 year cidadas. Enough of them splat on your windshield and you can't see where you're going. Good thing alpha particles don't have drivers. They could really have screwed up the data.

jimmy p
Sep29-03, 04:19 PM
PF Gold
jimmy p's Avatar
P: 580
Yeah if u think about it an alpha particle is a He2+ ion, so is approximately 3000 times (i think) the size of an electron so there is no worries about electrons, even with their high mass/charge ratio, affecting the path of the alpha particles. Electrons are seen as waves AND particles depending on the way their interactions are explained. Because theories on electrons having wave like properties, hadnt really been developed until Einstein was around, electrons are classed as particles. If they were waves anyway, surely the interactions would have no affect, all they would do is provide energy but in not enough proportions to affect a high energy stream of massive particles
Oct29-03, 10:36 PM
P: 310
does anyone mean the deep inelastic collision of electrons?
jimmy p
Dec3-03, 12:15 PM
PF Gold
jimmy p's Avatar
P: 580
I shouldnt think so...what's that anyway?

Register to reply

Related Discussions
The instability of Rutherford's atomic model Advanced Physics Homework 3
Rutherford's atomic model Introductory Physics Homework 0
Rutherford's Gold Leaf experiment with Beta Radiation General Physics 1
Rutherford's analysis Atomic, Solid State, Comp. Physics 2
Rutherford's Gold Leaf exp. Quantum Physics 6