Register to reply

Natural selection needs the feeling?

by gma
Tags: natural, selection
Share this thread:
gma
#1
Jul29-07, 09:37 AM
P: 3
Human(at least) has their feelings, such as anger, happiness, and depression, etc. But, is there an advantage for the survival of human being?? why natural selection choose the human being who has feelings??

I thought about this theme at last night. But, I don't get the answer. Help me :)
Phys.Org News Partner Biology news on Phys.org
Scottish zoo: 'Bad news' for pregnant giant panda
DNA may have had humble beginnings as nutrient carrier
Central biobank for drug research
Moonbear
#2
Aug4-07, 11:19 AM
Emeritus
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
Moonbear's Avatar
P: 12,270
Quote Quote by gma View Post
Human(at least) has their feelings, such as anger, happiness, and depression, etc. But, is there an advantage for the survival of human being?? why natural selection choose the human being who has feelings??

I thought about this theme at last night. But, I don't get the answer. Help me :)
I can only speculate if there is an advantage, and that it may be to hold together social bonds for humans to work better together in groups and delegate tasks. Some feelings may not be an advantage, and may either be detrimental (the reason we consider depression an ailment of a few rather than a normal trait of the majority), or neutral (no positive or negative effect, it's just there). Natural selection describes a process, not a thing with sentience to make choices, so you'll drive yourself batty if you try to make sense of it all in the context of natural selection "choosing" traits.

Some traits may simply persist because there was never another trait to replace it. Or, they may be linked to some other more beneficial trait. For example, perhaps higher intelligence that aids in survival cannot develop without the emotional centers of the brain. Emotion may not be important, but it only fails to exist in the absence of a functional level of intelligence.


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Is natural selection driven by intelligence? Biology 59
Evolution = years of natural selection? Biology 16
Cosmic Natural Selection Astronomy & Astrophysics 72
Natural selection or Societal selection? Biology 16
A Flaw in the Theory of Natural Selection? General Discussion 87