Logic Question


by almoo
Tags: logic
almoo
almoo is offline
#1
Jan7-09, 12:19 PM
P: 2
Honestly, I have no clue how to answer this question. A professor sent this out in a email, but I don't have a class with her so I don't think its homework. Care to throw some ideas? Is it really simple...? Apparently its a logic question, but it seems illogical to me.


"A mathematician is stranded on an island and is captured by a group of cannibals. They tell him that he gets to choose his way to die. The cannibals will shoot him if the next statement he says is true, and they will hang him if the next statement he says is false. The mathematician makes a statement and the cannibals have to let him go. What did the mathematician say?"
Phys.Org News Partner Science news on Phys.org
Better thermal-imaging lens from waste sulfur
Hackathon team's GoogolPlex gives Siri extra powers
Bright points in Sun's atmosphere mark patterns deep in its interior
sm1t
sm1t is offline
#2
Jan7-09, 12:50 PM
P: 6
I guess something like, "this statement is false", which is a sort of paradox, so because it can be neither true nor false, they release him.
stewartcs
stewartcs is offline
#3
Jan7-09, 04:10 PM
Sci Advisor
stewartcs's Avatar
P: 2,283
It's called a Liar's Paradox.

CS

Rogerio
Rogerio is offline
#4
Jan7-09, 07:57 PM
P: 403

Logic Question


Quote Quote by almoo View Post
"A mathematician is stranded on an island and is captured by a group of cannibals. They tell him that he gets to choose his way to die. The cannibals will shoot him if the next statement he says is true, and they will hang him if the next statement he says is false. The mathematician makes a statement and the cannibals have to let him go. What did the mathematician say?"
The mathematician just said:
"You will hang me."
CRGreathouse
CRGreathouse is offline
#5
Jan7-09, 10:45 PM
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 3,680
Quote Quote by Rogerio View Post
The mathematician just said:
"You will hang me."
So they shot him as he hung.
MathematicalPhysicist
MathematicalPhysicist is offline
#6
Jan7-09, 11:50 PM
P: 3,173
Well, the question is who decides what is truthfull, the cannibals or the mathematician? (-:
MathematicalPhysicist
MathematicalPhysicist is offline
#7
Jan7-09, 11:52 PM
P: 3,173
He could also decide not to talk, and then nothing happens.
stewartcs
stewartcs is offline
#8
Jan8-09, 07:46 AM
Sci Advisor
stewartcs's Avatar
P: 2,283
Quote Quote by loop quantum gravity View Post
He could also decide not to talk, and then nothing happens.
The riddle states that he makes a statement and then they let him go.

CS
HallsofIvy
HallsofIvy is offline
#9
Jan8-09, 10:05 AM
Math
Emeritus
Sci Advisor
Thanks
PF Gold
P: 38,879
As Rogerio says, he says "you will hang me". If the cannibals believe that is true, then they must shoot him which makes his statement false and so they must hang him. If the cannibals believe that is false, they must hang him which makes it true so they must shoot him. Either way violates what they said.
almoo
almoo is offline
#10
Jan8-09, 12:39 PM
P: 2
Thanks guys. I think i can follow what Rogerio said. Makes sense to me.
poutsos.A
poutsos.A is offline
#11
Jan28-09, 07:21 PM
P: 101
If he tells them look ,every Sunday i play football, what will the cannibals do??
Rogerio
Rogerio is offline
#12
Jan29-09, 09:14 PM
P: 403
Quote Quote by poutsos.A View Post
If he tells them look ,every Sunday i play football, what will the cannibals do??
This answer doesn't help him...
If the cannibals believe him, they whill shoot him.
And if they don't, they will hang him.
Rogerio
Rogerio is offline
#13
Jan29-09, 09:17 PM
P: 403
Anyway, he will stop to play football.
So, I guess the cannibals will hang him.
poutsos.A
poutsos.A is offline
#14
Jan30-09, 05:38 AM
P: 101
Does his life depend on what the cannibals believe or not??or whether the statement is true or false??
Rogerio
Rogerio is offline
#15
Jan30-09, 04:45 PM
P: 403
Quote Quote by poutsos.A View Post
Does his life depend on what the cannibals believe or not??or whether the statement is true or false??
If the statement is true, then the cannibals will shoot him.
But what specifically would be driving the cannibals? A magical force? A lie detector?
How can they know? Maybe they are very sensitive, and they can "feel" that?
Well, I prefer to think that the cannibals themselves decide whether the statement is true or not.
Rogerio
Rogerio is offline
#16
Jan30-09, 04:51 PM
P: 403
Anyway, his life (or death) depends on what the cannibals believe.


Register to reply

Related Discussions
please help:::logic question Engineering, Comp Sci, & Technology Homework 1
Logic Question! General Math 4
Logic Question Calculus & Beyond Homework 1
Logic question Biology, Chemistry & Other Homework 0
Logic question General Discussion 14