Register to reply 
Earth, Sun, Moon Orbit 
Share this thread: 
#1
Feb112, 03:30 PM

P: 44

Why does the Earth orbit the Sun, but the Moon pull on Earth's tides? Earth orbits the sun, proving that the Sun has a greater gravitational pull on the Earth than the Moon. However, the Moon control's Earth's tides (unlike the Sun), which proves the oppositethe Moon has a greater gravitational pull than the Sun.
So which one (Sun or Moon) have a greater gravitational pull on the Earth. 


#2
Feb112, 03:55 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
Thanks
P: 26,148

Hi Natko! Welcome to PF!
What matters is the gradient of the gravitational field … the rate at which the gravity increases or decreaes with height. Since the field is proportional to 1/r^{2}, its gradient is proportional to 1/r^{3}. The Sun's mass is so much greater than the Moon's mass that the tiny 1/r^{2} factor still leaves the Sun winning on ordinary gravitational strength. But the even tinier 1/r^{3} factor for tidal effects leaves the Moon winning (though not by much)! 


#3
Feb112, 05:06 PM

P: 44

Can you explain this in more understandable terms as I am only in Grade 9 please, especially what you mean by "gradient," "field," and the "1/r3 factor". 


#4
Feb112, 05:29 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
Thanks
P: 26,148

Earth, Sun, Moon Orbit
Hi Natko!
For "field", read "force" instead. "Gradient" is how fast the force changes as you go away from the Sun (or Moon). You probably know that the force of gravity is proportional to 1/r^{2}, where r is the distance from the Sun (or Moon) … if you draw a graph of y = 1/x^{2}, you see that it flattens out pretty fast as x gets larger but its slope (the gradient) flattens out even faster still. (i'm going to bed now … would anyone else like to carry on from there? ) 


#5
Feb112, 06:56 PM

Mentor
P: 11,892

Both the Moon and the Earth orbit the Sun, which is probably not how you've heard it before. But it's true! Since the gradiant of the Sun's gravity has fallen off so much out hear at Earth, the water on each side doesn't feel much of a difference. However, while the Moon is much less massive than the Sun, it is also much much closer. As tinytim pointed out, the gradiant falls off faster than the strength. So the different sides of the Earth feel a much greater difference in the strength of gravity from the Moon. What happens is that the Moon pulls the near side the strongest, then the middle of the Earth a little less, and then the opposite side even less. The Moon pulls the water on the near side towards it leading to a high tide there, then it pulls the rest of the Earth AWAY from the water on the other side, leading to a high tide there as well, with low tides in between. 


#6
Feb112, 07:54 PM

Mentor
P: 15,170

[tex]a_{\text{earth}} = \frac{GM_{\text{moon}}}{R^2}[/tex] where G is the universal gravitational constant, M_{moon}, and R is the distance between the center of the moon and the center of the earth. Now imagine a drop of water on the surface of the earth directly on the line from the earth to the moon. This drop of water is a bit closer to the moon than is the center of the earth. Denoting the radius of the earth with a lower case r, the distance between the drop and the moon is Rr. This shorter distance means the drop experiences a slightly greater acceleration than does the earth as a whole: [tex]a_{\text{drop}} = \frac{GM_{\text{moon}}}{(Rr)^2}[/tex] Factoring R out of Rr yields [itex]Rr=R(1r/R)[/itex]. Thus another way to write the acceleration of the drop is [tex]a_{\text{drop}} = \frac{GM_{\text{moon}}}{R^2}\frac1{(1r/R)^2}[/tex] The acceleration of the drop relative to the earth as a whole is simply the difference between these: [tex]\begin{aligned} a_{\text{rel}} &= \frac{GM_{\text{moon}}}{(Rr)^2}  \frac{GM_{\text{moon}}}{R^2} \\ &= \frac{GM_{\text{moon}}}{R^2}\frac1{(1r/R)^2}  \frac{GM_{\text{moon}}}{R^2} \\ &= \frac{GM_{\text{moon}}}{R^2}\left(\frac1{(1r/R)^2}1\right) \end{aligned}[/tex] The first term in parentheses can be rewritten as [tex]\frac1{(1r/R)^2} = 1+2\frac r R + 3\left(\frac r R\right)^2 + 4\left(\frac r R\right)^3 + \cdots[/tex] With this, the acceleration of the drop relative to the earth becomes [tex]\begin{aligned} a_{\text{rel}} &= \frac{GM_{\text{moon}}}{R^2}\left(\frac1{(1r/R)^2}1\right) \\ &= \frac{GM_{\text{moon}}}{R^2} \left(2\frac r R + 3\left(\frac r R\right)^2 + 4\left(\frac r R\right)^3 + \cdots\right) \end{aligned}[/tex] Because the distance to the moon or the sun is much greater than the radius of the earth, the first term is going to be the dominant one. Thus [tex] a_{\text{rel}} \approx \frac{GM_{\text{moon}}}{R^2} 2\frac r R = \frac{2GM_{\text{moon}}r}{R^3} [/tex] So, 1/R^{3}. Substitute the moon for the sun and the same kind of inverse cube relation will hold. 


#7
Feb112, 08:02 PM

P: 44




#8
Feb112, 08:03 PM

P: 44




#9
Feb212, 07:00 AM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
Thanks
P: 26,148

Hi Natko!
(just got up … ) Imagine a spaceship in space, pointing away from the Sun (it can be orbiting, or falling, it doesn't matter). The gravity on the bottom of the spaceship is stronger than the gravity on the top. If the spaceship was stretchy, this difference in force would stretch it. The closer the spaceship is to the Sun, the bigger the difference, and so the bigger the stretching force. Near a black hole, the difference is very strong, and the extreme stretching there (of spaceships or of astronauts) is popularly known as "spaghettification". Of course, physicists don't call it "stretching force", they call it "tidal force". Let's calculate how much the stretching force is. Suppose the spaceship has length L, and suppose its centre is at distance R from the centre of the Sun. Then the gravity on the bottom of the spaceship is proportional to 1/(R  L/2)^{2}, and the gravity on the top of the spaceship is proportional to 1/(R + L/2)^{2} (slightly less). The difference is 1/(R  L/2)^{2}  1/(R + L/2)^{2} = ((R + L/2)^{2}  (R  L/2)^{2})/((R + L/2)^{2}(R  L/2)^{2}) = 2RL/(R^{2}  L^{2}/4)^{2} which if L is very much less than R, is very nearly 2RL/R^{4}, or 2L/R^{3}. So the difference in force on a spaceship of length L is 2L/R^{3} … ie the stretching force per length is proportional to 1/R^{3}. Water is stretchy (well, it flows, which has the same effect ), and so the water round the Earth is stretched away from the centre of the Earth, in line with the Sun. This stretching ("tidal") force is proportional to 1/R^{3}. There is of course also a stretching force cause by the Moon, proportional to 1/R_{Moon}^{3}, where R_{Moon} is the distance to the Moon. The Sun is about 400 times further from us than the Moon is (R/R_{Moon} ~ 400), 


#10
Feb212, 07:24 AM

P: 366

Write for your target audience! 


#11
Feb212, 07:49 AM

Mentor
P: 15,170




#12
Feb212, 07:56 AM

P: 366

Anyways this was in no way intended to be rude or as a criticism! I am sure your efforts are appreciated and I have seen a number of very good posts from you which have helped me. Cosmo 


#13
Feb212, 03:30 PM

P: 44

And since the Sun is farther away from Earth than the moon is, it has a smaller gradient/tidal force. Thus, this causes the Moon to pull on one side of the Earth, creating a tide on each side, and the Sun has an effect on the entire Earth, pulling it into orbit. But the Sun still has a stronger gravitational pull on the Earth than the Moon does, even the gradient/tidal force is smaller. 


#14
Feb212, 04:22 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
Thanks
P: 26,148

that's why there's a tidal bulge on both sides of the Earth (facing the Moon and opposite), ie two high tides every day! The Moon stretches the water on both sides of the Earth, the Sun does the same, but less so (much smaller tidal bulges), and both the Moon and the Sun affect the Earth's path through space. 


#15
Feb212, 04:47 PM

P: 44




#16
Feb212, 05:00 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
Thanks
P: 26,148

I explained that earlier, and I though you agreed. Well, stretching is a bothways effect … just try stretching something by pulling on only one end! If you watch the Earth and Moon from "above", you'll see that they sortof dance round each other! 


#17
Feb212, 05:38 PM

P: 44




#18
Feb212, 05:40 PM

P: 44

Although the Moon has an effect on Earth's movement, it's the Sun's gravitational pull that Earth to orbit it, right?



Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Orbit of Moon and the earth around thier COM  Introductory Physics Homework  5  
Why does the Moon orbit the Earth rather than the Sun?  Astronomy & Astrophysics  6  
Will the Moon escape Earth's orbit in billions of years?  Astronomy & Astrophysics  8  
If a comet kicks the moon out of its orbit and away from earth...  General Physics  4  
How closely could the Moon orbit the Earth  Astronomy & Astrophysics  17 