Proper summation notation


by Niles
Tags: notation, proper, summation
Niles
Niles is offline
#1
Mar27-12, 02:05 PM
P: 1,863
Hi

Is it correct of me to say that I want to carry out the sum
[tex]
\sum_i{v_iw_i}
[/tex]
where [itex]i\in\{x,y,z\}[/itex]? Or is it most correct to say that [itex]i=\{x,y,z\}[/itex]?

Best regards,
Niles.
Phys.Org News Partner Mathematics news on Phys.org
Researchers help Boston Marathon organizers plan for 2014 race
'Math detective' analyzes odds for suspicious lottery wins
Pseudo-mathematics and financial charlatanism
Office_Shredder
Office_Shredder is offline
#2
Mar27-12, 02:18 PM
Mentor
P: 4,499
If you have the sum
[tex] v_x w_x + v_y w_y + v_z w_z[/tex]
then you want [itex] i \in \{ x,y,z \} [/itex], which says sum over every element of the set [itex] \{x,y,z \}[/itex]. If you wrote
[tex] \sum_{i=\{x,y,z \}} v_i w_i[/tex] what you really just wrote is
[tex] v_{ \{x,y,z \}} w_{ \{x,y,z \}}[/tex]
which is strange because it's not a sum, and because indices are unlikely (but might be) sets of variables
Niles
Niles is offline
#3
Mar27-12, 02:20 PM
P: 1,863
Thanks, that is also what I thought was the case. I see the "i={x,y,z}"-version in all sorts of books.

Best wishes,
Niles.

chiro
chiro is offline
#4
Mar27-12, 08:49 PM
P: 4,570

Proper summation notation


Quote Quote by Niles View Post
Hi

Is it correct of me to say that I want to carry out the sum
[tex]
\sum_i{v_iw_i}
[/tex]
where [itex]i\in\{x,y,z\}[/itex]? Or is it most correct to say that [itex]i=\{x,y,z\}[/itex]?

Best regards,
Niles.
While one can interpret that, it would make more sense if associated an index set with your label set if you need to do this. So if instead of {x,y,z} just introduce the bijection {x,y,z} = {1,2,3} where the ith component of one set maps to the ith of the other.

This is just my opinion, but the reason is mostly conventional because its easier for everyone with a simple mathematics background to understand and causes less confusion.
Niles
Niles is offline
#5
Mar28-12, 02:19 AM
P: 1,863
Thanks for the help, that is kind of everybody.

Best,
Niles.


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Summation notation General Math 2
Summation Notation. General Math 3
Summation Notation Special & General Relativity 2
Proper notation on this site General Physics 1
Summation notation Precalculus Mathematics Homework 6