
#1
Apr612, 08:49 AM

P: 132

I'm having a little problem with my book as I was reading about fluid mechanics. The book seems to have skipped a bit of some crucial part (at least for me) during the derivation for fluid pressure at certain depths (where the weight of the fluid is not neglected).
Here, I'll try to reconstruct the derivation and try to point out the parts where it confused me. First suppose we have a fluid with definite volume where its density is the same throughout, hence it's uniform. Now, if we take an element fluid with thickness dy then and its top and bottom surfaces are the same, say A. Its volume is dV=A*dy, it's mass dm=(rho)*dV=(rho)*A*dy, and its weight w is dmg=(rho)*g*A*dy. Where rho is the density of the fluid. When the book gave an analysis of the forces on the ycomponent of that certain element fluid, the upward force is given by F(upward) = pA. I understand that part since there is pressure (p) pressing the fluid at its bottom area. Now, when the book gave the downward forces, it's given by F(downward) = (p+dp)*A and this confused me, where did the additional dp come from? There is the p that presses the upper area of the fluid but what about dp? Also the other downward force is the weight, but the fluid is in equilibrium, so: (Sum)Fy = pA(p+dp)*AW=0 *The fact that there is force p*A upward and downward plus the weight is also non intuitive for me.* So yeah, the biggest question for me is dp in the derivation, what is that? 



#2
Apr612, 10:32 AM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
Thanks
P: 26,167

hi mathsciguy!
(have a rho: ρ ) then the force upward at height y is Ap(y), and the force downward at height y+dy is Ap(y+dy), = A{p(y) + dp} (where dp = (dp/dy) dy) so the total force downward (excluding gravity) is A{p(y) + dp}  Ap(y) = Adp(and dp will be negative because y is height, not depth ) 



#3
Apr612, 11:03 AM

P: 132

Thanks, I thought no one would reply since my post was kinda messy.
So the pressure really is different at differing altitudes, but I thought that was caused by considering the force done by the gravity I.e. the weight. Since there is weight then it gives a downward pressure at the top surface (of course I know that if I think of it like that then the element fluid will not be in equilibrium, but I think that's another question). I've thought of that, since from what I know, if we consider the case where there is negligible force done by the gravity then the pressure is the same throughout the volume of the fluid, it's the same even if we consider the pressure done by fluid onto a part of itself. Edit: I think, my confusion is caused by not being sure of why pressure vary in altitude. Would it vary in altitude if we neglect the weight of the fluid? 



#4
Apr612, 12:18 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
Thanks
P: 26,167

Fluid Mechanics, Depth, Pressurepressure = force per area, and the only force downward is the weight of the fluid above 



#5
Apr612, 12:33 PM

P: 132

Not considering dy, Fnet = Ap(y)wAp(y) = ma *Well, because I thought at both top and bottom A there is that same pressure p, we just got an additional pressure done by w. I kind of get it now though, if we solve for the net force on parallel to gravity we could see that Adp=W, and this makes sense to me now. Many thanks sir tinytim. 



#6
Apr612, 12:36 PM

P: 132

Not considering dy, Fnet = Ap(y)wAp(y) = ma *Well, because I thought at both top and bottom A there is that same pressure p, we just got an additional pressure done by w. I kind of get it now though, if we solve for the net force on the yaxis we could see that Adp=W, and this makes sense to me now. It's kind of not very intuitive to see that Adp is an upward force. (I might be wrong all together on this, I hope not) Many thanks sir tinytim. 



#7
Apr612, 02:13 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
Thanks
P: 26,167





#8
Apr612, 02:34 PM

P: 132




Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Pressure and depth in a static fluid  Introductory Physics Homework  1  
Fluid Mechanics  Air Pressure/ Prism  Classical Physics  1  
Pressure energy(fluid mechanics)  Classical Physics  9  
Fluid Mechanics, Pressure  Classical Physics  8  
Fluid Mechanics  Pressure measurements  Introductory Physics Homework  2 