New Reply

noob time-space thought problem

 
Share Thread
Apr17-12, 08:33 PM   #1
 

noob time-space thought problem


this one bothers me - pls point out the flaw in my reasoning:

Time-space may be called a 'fabric', and may be depicted as a 2D 'sheet'. An object with mass deforms the sheet.

If i were to grab one edge of this 'inelastic sheet' and pull it 1 cm, would the movement would be instantaneous across the sheet .. i.e... any one point of the sheet moves just 1 cm, but the distant edge, many light-years away, also *immediately* moves towards me 1 cm. too?

Or, would the tension I create warp the 'elastic sheet', and so cause my immediately surrounding fabric to move ~1 cm, but stretching the fabric so that the distant part only responded to the tug over some much longer time period, analogous to pulling a rubber sheet of the same size.

Would the transfer of this pull across the sheet be faster/slower/the same speed of light?
PhysOrg.com science news on PhysOrg.com

>> City-life changes blackbird personalities, study shows
>> Origins of 'The Hoff' crab revealed (w/ Video)
>> Older males make better fathers: Mature male beetles work harder, care less about female infidelity
Apr17-12, 08:35 PM   #2
 
Don't take the rubber sheet analogy too literally.

The very quick answer to your question is that curvature of space-time is what gravity is, so gravitational waves, and thus changes in the curvature, are presumed to travel at c.
Apr19-12, 11:13 PM   #3
 
ok thanks!
New Reply

Tags
gravity, relativity, time-space

Similar discussions for: noob time-space thought problem
Thread Forum Replies
Thought - Euclidean Space R^(-n) Linear & Abstract Algebra 7
Curvature of space/time question/problem Special & General Relativity 5
Noob question: If you travel as fast as light, time freezes so... Special & General Relativity 52
Space-Time gravitational field problem Special & General Relativity 5
A question about a thought experiment in space Special & General Relativity 55