|Aug30-12, 01:25 AM||#1|
Visualizing General Relativity with Fluid Analogy
I'm interested in using a fluid analogy of general relativity to more easily visual what is going on in certain situations, with out having to resort to visualizing curved 4d space time which is doesn't come to naturally.
However, I don't know relativity quite well enough to understand what the nature of the fluid would be, or even if it is possible to specify a fluid type of metric that can replicate all the effects of GR.
GR is often introduced with the ball rolling on rubber sheet analogy, which I always found more confusing then helpful, because it is meant to show how curved space causes a ball to fall into a dip, but in that analogy, the force of gravity is what pulls the ball down the slope, so it doesn't actually help explain much. It isn't just space that is curved, it is space time.
Instead I have always imagined the idea of space flowing into objects. What I would now like to understand better is, what would be the nature of flow, and where does this analogy break down.
If one was to create an animation, in 2D, of an object, with space flowing into it, how would it look? I imagine that the density of space would change as gravity increases. I would imagine that such an animation would give a much more intuitive idea of what is happening in GR, although, I could imagine some people may not like it because it is suggestive of some time of redundant dynamic ether.
|Aug30-12, 02:36 AM||#2|
http://www.relativitet.se/Webarticle...sson74p905.pdf (chapter VII)
Non fluid analogies, which avoid the problems of the rolling on rubber sheet explanation :
|Aug30-12, 03:24 AM||#3|
|Similar Threads for: Visualizing General Relativity with Fluid Analogy|
|How much is Special Relativity a needed foundation of General Relativity||Special & General Relativity||97|
|Making analogy between fluid mechanical and electrical system||Classical Physics||4|
|relativity-variation-fluid||Special & General Relativity||0|
|General Frame Covariance in Achronal Quantum General Relativity (was:||General Physics||0|
|Special Relativity vs. General Relativity||Special & General Relativity||25|