New Reply

Question about quantum physics and possible shortcomings

 
Share Thread
Sep8-12, 11:53 PM   #1
 

Question about quantum physics and possible shortcomings


I was originally an applied math major and about 2 years ago doubled up with a major in physics... Being an applied math major, I have had quite a few courses in mathematical modeling, and there was always something that bugged me about quantum physics. I figured that I would figure it out once I finally took a couple of courses in quantum, and even asked my professor, but this question has yet to be answered for me:

The Schrodinger equation is a mathematical model, or sometimes also referred to as a deterministic model... So why in the world are we associating a probabilistic function with it?

I'm not saying that it's wrong or that it doesn't provide insight, because it most definitely does and obviously has provided quite a revolution in modern technology. However, it does seem rather limiting to use a mathematical model in such a way...

Does anyone understand what I'm saying? Any insight would be greatly appreciated.
PhysOrg.com physics news on PhysOrg.com

>> Is there an invisible tug-of-war behind bad hearts and power outages?
>> Penetrating the quantum nature of magnetism
>> Rethinking the universe: Groundbreaking theory proposed in 1997 suggests a 'multiverse'
Sep9-12, 01:31 AM   #2
 
Recognitions:
Science Advisor Science Advisor
Quote by galoisjr View Post
The Schrodinger equation is a mathematical model, or sometimes also referred to as a deterministic model... So why in the world are we associating a probabilistic function with it?
The Schrödinger equation determines a wave function w/o any uncertainty, probability, indeterminism or something like that. But what we are doing is to interpret this wave function as a probability density (of finding a single particle in a certain region).
Sep9-12, 08:09 AM   #3
 
Mentor
Quote by galoisjr View Post
The Schrodinger equation is a mathematical model, or sometimes also referred to as a deterministic model... So why in the world are we associating a probabilistic function with it?
Because experimental outcomes are probabilistic, in general, as far as we know.
New Reply

Similar discussions for: Question about quantum physics and possible shortcomings
Thread Forum Replies
Fuzzy Theory applied to Quantum Physics and Quantum Computing as a career in physics. Career Guidance 2
shortcomings of quantum theory General Discussion 26
What are the shortcomings of Misner, Thorne, Wheeler? Special & General Relativity 21
Quantum physics & Atomic Physics Question Introductory Physics Homework 3