Register to reply

Beam welded to plate. Plate stress?

by Engineer_Phil
Tags: beam, plate, stress, welded
Share this thread:
Engineer_Phil
#1
Jan9-13, 01:53 PM
P: 27
I have a design where a beam gets welded to a plate. The plate is not against a wall or foundation, but for simplicity I can say that the edges of the plate are fixed. I am concerned about the stress in the plate, and the deflection in the beam. I have access to solidworks simulation, but I want to know if anyone knows of an analytical solution or experimental solution that I can compare to. I don't like to just blindly trust a simulation.
I have attached an image of my setup. In the future I want to vary the beam cross section size and style.
Attached Thumbnails
Capture.JPG  
Phys.Org News Partner Engineering news on Phys.org
Greater safety and security at Europe's train stations
Fingerprints for freight items
On the way to a safe and secure smart home
Windadct
#2
Jan11-13, 05:12 PM
P: 564
The process and quality of the weld is critical - welding is MUCH more organic than people recognize.
Engineer_Phil
#3
Jan14-13, 11:38 AM
P: 27
We have qualified welding procedures and a good quality control program the welding should be fine. I am more concerned about how to determine the required thickness of the plate. The stress cannot exceed 20 kpsi.

Windadct
#4
Jan15-13, 02:11 PM
P: 564
Beam welded to plate. Plate stress?

Do you mean the stress caused by the welding - or how much stress the weldament can withstand once complete?
For stress caused by the weld - there are different ways to make the weld, different processes and different electrode types. The determination of the HAZ will have a large impact in both the stress created by the process and how much the weld can take.
Probably the best is to get the datasheet for the electrodes your best welder would like to use.
I do think Solidworks has a simulator for welds - but you will need to know the parameters of the weld process and electrodes details.
pongo38
#5
Jan15-13, 03:45 PM
P: 699
An elastic analysis will tell you how the stress changes due to the applied load, but not take account of the residual stresses from welding, and takes no account of stress redistribution after the first yield of the steel. Plastic theory or yield line theory will give a good indication of the collapse load, but give no information on the working load behaviour.
Vadar2012
#6
Jan15-13, 11:23 PM
P: 208
If I was doing this, I'd trust the simulation more than any theoretical hand calculations. I've done something similar to this for work, but with something bolted to a corrugated steel sheet. To simplify the simlation, you can use simple statics to calculate the forces at the wall. Then just model only the plate in the simulation. What you're after is the stress on the plate around the beam and plate contact. An easy way to do this is make the contact surface a different element than the rest of the plate and turn it off when analysisng the results. This just gives you the stress on the plate.

In other words, simulation is the best way.
Engineer_Phil
#7
Jan18-13, 02:12 PM
P: 27
Thanks for the help guys.

I guess I have no choice but to accept the Simulation results as Vadar2012 suggests.
I am going to look at getting some strain gauges to verify the Simulation results.

I hope the simulation is wrong though... otherwise the plate is going to have to be very very thick.
Vadar2012
#8
Jan21-13, 08:44 PM
P: 208
Yeah, I found it was larger than I thought. Will be interesting to hear about the strain gauge results.
Engineer_Phil
#9
Jan22-13, 12:04 PM
P: 27
Quote Quote by Vadar2012 View Post
Yeah, I found it was larger than I thought. Will be interesting to hear about the strain gauge results.
Did you run an FEA? I'd like to compare results if you did.
Vadar2012
#10
Jan23-13, 05:13 PM
P: 208
Quote Quote by Engineer_Phil View Post
Did you run an FEA? I'd like to compare results if you did.
Can't run one on yours, don't have any info.
Engineer_Phil
#11
Jan24-13, 10:36 AM
P: 27
I made a simple drawing to give you the data.

A picture is worth a thousand words.

Attached Thumbnails
problem data.JPG  
0xDEADBEEF
#12
Jan24-13, 05:08 PM
P: 825
Just out of interest: How would you use strain gauges with this. Do you glue them on beforehand and then measure the resistance before and after? Do they survive welding temperatures?
RFreund
#13
Jan24-13, 07:32 PM
P: 1
What is the plate attached to? AISC give some guidance on welding plates to walls of HSS (hollow structural steel). Also Blodget's Design of Welded Structures also covers this.
Engineer_Phil
#14
Jan25-13, 01:50 PM
P: 27
Quote Quote by 0xDEADBEEF View Post
Just out of interest: How would you use strain gauges with this. Do you glue them on beforehand and then measure the resistance before and after? Do they survive welding temperatures?
I am not really concerned with residual stresses from welding at this point. I would weld the beam to the plate, then put the strain gauge on the back side of the plate directly behind the bottom of the beam. Then load the beam. And take the strain gauge measurement.
Jupiter6
#15
Jan25-13, 11:29 PM
P: 128
Quote Quote by Engineer_Phil View Post
Thanks for the help guys.

I guess I have no choice but to accept the Simulation results....
Accepting a simulations answer (especially Solidworks) without an approximate paper answer to corroborate it is never the way to do something correctly.

Check out Timoshenko's Theory of Plates and Shells. I don't think you'll find this to be as difficult as you think it is.
PhanthomJay
#16
Jan26-13, 10:29 PM
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
PF Gold
PhanthomJay's Avatar
P: 6,043
I would think that Roarke's "Stress and Strain" would give a solution, but i don't have a copy right now. But being very conservative by assuming simple supports along the short edges and free along the long side, I get a 5/8" thick plate required using a hand calc on the back of a matchbook. Looks like a 1/2 inch plate will do, as you have drawn. But someone needs to quality review my work
M_max in beam at beam/plate interface = 3(12) = 36 in-k
Load to short edge = M/L = 36/18 = 2 kips
M_max in plate at plate/beam interface = 2(6) = 12 in-k
S_req'd = M/allowable stress = 12/20 = 0.6 in^3
t_required = sq rt( 6S/b) = sq rt(6(.6)/10) = 0.6 in

Is a 5/8" plate too thick for you? i wouldn't cut it back too much...why fool with it.
nvn
#17
Jan27-13, 05:59 PM
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 2,124
PhanthomJay: Roark does not seem to contain the given problem. Nice approach. Using your approach, I get the same answer you got, except a different allowable stress (and therefore a different wall plate thickness). I currently do not know how you got your allowable stress. My allowable bending stress is currently, Sta = 197 MPa. Therefore, I currently obtain the following wall plate thickness (t1), using your above approach.
t1 = sqrt[3(1 - h2/h1)*L*V/(b1*Sta)] = 12.75 mm,
where b1 = wall plate width, h1 = wall plate height, h2 = cantilever beam plate height, L = cantilever beam length, and V = cantilever transverse tip load.
PhanthomJay
#18
Jan28-13, 05:25 AM
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
PF Gold
PhanthomJay's Avatar
P: 6,043
Quote Quote by nvn View Post
PhanthomJay: Roark does not seem to contain the given problem. Nice approach. Using your approach, I get the same answer you got, except a different allowable stress (and therefore a different wall plate thickness). I currently do not know how you got your allowable stress. My allowable bending stress is currently, Sta = 197 MPa. Therefore, I currently obtain the following wall plate thickness (t1), using your above approach.
t1 = sqrt[3(1 - h2/h1)*L*V/(b1*Sta)] = 12.75 mm,
where b1 = wall plate width, h1 = wall plate height, h2 = cantilever beam plate height, L = cantilever beam length, and V = cantilever transverse tip load.
Thanks for the check..the alowable stress of 20,000 pounds per square inch (138 MPa) was later introduced by the OP in post 3.


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Parallel plate capacitor's plate distance is doubled, does the energy double? Introductory Physics Homework 1
Electron in a parallel plate capacitor - finding plate's magnitude Introductory Physics Homework 4
A proton is released from rest at the positive plate of a parallel-plate capacitor. Introductory Physics Homework 16
Plate top vonmises stress in fea Engineering Systems & Design 1
Electron in a parallel plate capacitor - finding plate's magnitude Introductory Physics Homework 4