Please help me with multiple comparisons - urgent (stats)

by mintsharpie
Tags: comparisons, multiple, stats, urgent
mintsharpie is offline
Feb11-13, 01:05 AM
P: 3
Hello, I just have a quick question understanding multiple comparisons and I'd appreciate any help because I'm on the verge of failing I'm reviewing for a test, and reading over questions and their corresponding answers in the back of the textbook. The question I'm stuck on deals with a psychologist testing the claim made by a drug company that a drug would help patients.

To do this, they selected 20 patients from their hospital, and randomly assigned them to one of four groups - group 1 receiving the new drug, group 2 receiving a different drug, group 3 receiving a different drug, and group 4 as the control group. Here is the answer given in the textbook:

I understand the first part, and how SSE is calculated and everything, but the second table with the contrasts totally baffles me. I have no idea how that table was filled in, or how I would be able to fill it in on a test if I had a different example. How were those 1s, -1s, and 2s determined? What do they mean and how were they calculated? In addition, once I go on to the appropriate post hoc test - in this case, Dunn - how do I utilise the table in terms of critical values?

Please help me, I'm so very lost!
Phys.Org News Partner Science news on
Lemurs match scent of a friend to sound of her voice
Repeated self-healing now possible in composite materials
'Heartbleed' fix may slow Web performance
Stephen Tashi
Stephen Tashi is offline
Feb11-13, 10:29 AM
Sci Advisor
P: 3,167
I'm not an expert on this, but I was curious enough about the table to look up "Dunn Test" and found:

In the slide "What is a contrast anyway", it is explained that a contrast is a linear combination of means. For example, if the hypothesis [itex] \mu_A = \mu_B [/itex] is true then the contrast [itex] 1 \mu_A + (-1) \mu_B = 0 [/itex]. So I suspect the table gives you the coefficients (such as 1 and -1) that are involved in the contrast being tested. I don't know anything else about the subject.
mintsharpie is offline
Feb11-13, 11:43 AM
P: 3
I'm so confused, and I don't understand this at all

ssd is offline
Feb13-13, 02:02 PM
P: 239

Please help me with multiple comparisons - urgent (stats)

This is an "analysis of one way classified data".
In design of experiments you see it as CRD (completely randomized design).
The analysis is very straight forward.

Xi = ith observation
Ti= i th row total, G = sum of Ti. Then SS(T)= Sum(Ti*Ti/Ni)-cf, has df=4-1=3
where, cf= (G*G/N), Ni= values in i th row, N = sum of Ni.
SST= Sum(Xi*Xi)-cf, has df= 20-1=19.
SSE= SST-SS(T), has df=19-3=16.
F= MS(T)/MSE ~ F (3,16) (=> F distribution with 3,16 df)
MS(T)=SS(T)/3, MSE=SSE/16. Critical region:F> F(a,3,16). a=0.05 or 0.01 as you choose. Find F(a,3,16)
from Biometrica tables.

Register to reply

Related Discussions
URGENT HELP WITH STATS - Good sampling methods for this would be what? Set Theory, Logic, Probability, Statistics 1
Reject Value (Stats) (URGENT) Calculus & Beyond Homework 0
URGENT Stats Problem Calculus & Beyond Homework 0
Very urgent probability and stats question. Calculus & Beyond Homework 0
Urgent please stats Calculus & Beyond Homework 7