Mirror Color: Do Mirrors Have a Color?

  • Context: High School 
  • Thread starter Thread starter lwymarie
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Color Mirror
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the question of whether mirrors have a color, exploring the nature of color perception, reflection, and the properties of light. Participants engage in philosophical and technical reasoning regarding the definition of color and its dependence on various factors, including the characteristics of light and the materials involved.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Debate/contested
  • Technical explanation

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants suggest that a mirror reflects all wavelengths of light and could be considered white, as it absorbs none.
  • Others argue that no mirror is perfect, and the light that is not reflected alters the perceived color of the reflection.
  • A participant posits that the color of a mirror is a philosophical question, suggesting that it is defined by what it reflects.
  • There is a discussion about how the perceived color of an object is influenced by the light illuminating it and the object's properties.
  • One participant mentions that the reflection spectrum of mirrors is significant in optics, particularly in laser optics, and that coatings on lenses can affect their perceived color.
  • Some participants debate whether color is a human perception or if it can be attributed to other forms of electromagnetic radiation, such as infrared or ultraviolet.
  • There is a contention regarding whether animals perceive colors differently than humans, with references to dogs and bees seeing beyond the human color spectrum.
  • Participants express uncertainty about the nature of color perception and the mechanisms behind it, particularly in relation to consciousness and sensory experience.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants do not reach a consensus on whether mirrors have a color, with multiple competing views and ongoing debate about the nature of color perception and its dependence on various factors.

Contextual Notes

The discussion includes unresolved questions about the definitions of color, the influence of light on perception, and the complexities of sensory experience across different species.

lwymarie
Messages
89
Reaction score
1
the mirror only reflects light and produce image of other objects.
so what's the color of a mirror actually?
 
Science news on Phys.org
lwymarie said:
the mirror only reflects light and produce image of other objects.
so what's the color of a mirror actually?
I think that technically it would have to be considered white. The colour of an object is determined by what wavelengths it doesn't absorb. A true mirror absorbs none, and white light is composed of all visible frequencies, so...
 
Mirro mirror on the wall Who is the fairest of them all ?

There is no such thing as a perfect mirror . This means it reflects most but not all light . The light which is NOT reflected is missing in the reflection.
Therefore if the incident light is white -- then it is not white upon reflection.
A silvered mirror is almost perfect -- but a polished copper mirror is not
the surface absorbes some colors ( wavelengths of light ) and therefore causes a colored reflection
. Your Ray .
 
The way I would see it (pun intended) color is how we define what we see. Therefore the color is whatever the reflection is. To give the mirror a color is more of a philisophical question. Although you could well say the glass is colourless (transparent) and the material behind silver(y).

You could extend this to say what is the color of a piece of paper when in pitch black visibility, that would normally be white by day. Techinically the paper would be now black.
 
Delta said:
You could extend this to say what is the color of a piece of paper when in pitch black visibility, that would normally be white by day. Techinically the paper would be now black.

It's more than technically, it is how it is taught in colour theory.

The perceived colour of an object is determined by the properties of the light cast upon it.
The perceived colour of an object is influenced by the properties of the object.

Think about it. The range of colours that an object could have is rigidly bound by the range of light that illuminates it. FIRST.

Only then, can the properties of the object further determine - within that narrow range - a smaller subset of colours that the object will exhibit.


Blue light limits an object's possible colours to a blue range. A red ball will have to appear purple - or black.


P.S. "perceived colour" is redundant. Colour is - by definition - about perception. Objects do not have colour, they have ranges of frequency that they absorb or transmit. The red ball under the blue light absorbed all freqs of light that impinged on it, and transmited none. But this does not make the ball red.
 
Last edited:
The colour of a mirror (or any object) is defined by it's reflection spectrum when illuminated by a white source (I personally think a green ball in the dark is still a green ball).

The reflection spectra of mirrors is actually a very important characteristic in optics, particularly laser optics, so the colour of a mirror is not all that complex a question.

For example, most camera lenses have antireflection coatings to reduce Fresnal reflections. Since these coatings are optimised for the yellow/green part of the spectrum, the lenses (which can be regarded as mirrors - not all mirrors are 100% reflecting) have a purplish tinge because it reflects small parts of the blue and red spectrum, but not the green. The mirror is thus regarded as being 'purple' though you would never find a physicist officially regard it as such, but the purple colour of the mirror is quite obvious.

Claude.
 
To All
So a question remains does an object have a color ??
The answer is that it does ! and this is dependent upon it's temperature for most at room temerature that color is somewhere in the infra red .
Ray.
 
Is infra red a colour?

What colour are radio waves, gamma rays, etc.

I always thought of colour as a human perception, not as what EM waves are being emitted.
 
Depends on who you ask. Animals can see well outside the human range of colours. Dogs see into IR, bees see into UV.

I would argue that they see them as colours.
 
  • #10
Sorry Delta --- I use the term color to represent frequency or wavelenth it's just shorter to type . But as someone else said animals see out of our range, and 'see' in a general sense does mean to 'sense' so we 'see' infra red through feeling , and ultra violet through burning . As to Human perception God only knows what that means .
Yours Ray.
 
  • #11
DaveC426913 said:
Depends on who you ask. Animals can see well outside the human range of colours. Dogs see into IR, bees see into UV.

I would argue that they see them as colours.

Your saying that Dogs can see Prime colors that we can't? Hmn, do you think that there would be any way in the future to make humans see more colors then? :rolleyes: that'd be awsome
 
  • #12
Actually it is thought that dogs can only see black and white ( i.e greys )
but in electonic terms your question is simple it is just a matter of frequency change
. (in a theoretical sense ) We do this every day with satellie photos giving false color pictures of Radar images , infra red images etc.
Goto JPL and look at their image archives . They are almost never in true color .
Yours Ray .
 
  • #13
A prism is the best type of mirror, using internal reflection. Color changes from where you look at it.
 
  • #14
eNathan said:
Your saying that Dogs can see Prime colors that we can't? Hmn, do you think that there would be any way in the future to make humans see more colors then? :rolleyes: that'd be awsome
Well, the primary colours are dependent on what type of receptors the eye has. Humans have red green and blue receptors, thus those are our primary colours.

I don't know what type of receptors dogs have, but I'm sure a quick Google check will clarify. However, I doubt that they would have special IR receptors. This means they will merely see IR as a deeper red.
 
  • #15
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #16
What anybody 'sees' including dogs we have not a clue -- we can tell what they react to -- dogs do not react to visual color differences --bees do react to ultra violet.
When you say 'see' you mean some sort of internal visualisation ( which we cannot share anyway ) so you could ask does a bee 'see' ultra violet -- like you could ask does a pigeon 'see' magnetic fields. Here the question is one of conciousness and that is still a compete mystery.

Ray
 
  • #17
rayjohn01 said:
What anybody 'sees' including dogs we have not a clue -- we can tell what they react to -- dogs do not react to visual color differences --bees do react to ultra violet.
When you say 'see' you mean some sort of internal visualisation ( which we cannot share anyway ) so you could ask does a bee 'see' ultra violet -- like you could ask does a pigeon 'see' magnetic fields. Here the question is one of conciousness and that is still a compete mystery.

Ray
Ah, I would disgaree.

A bee literally sees UV. It is received by its optical receptors and processed the same. UV is just one other 'colour' in its field of view. As to exactly what the bee sees that colour as, I dunno.

OTOH, a pigeon does not have optical receptors that pick up magnetic fields. It is a distinct mechanism. Offhand I don't know what mechanism it is, but I would guess it is similar to our sense of balance (itty bitty grains float around in a vessel in our ear, and where they fall, they stimulate hairs. That is perceived by us as 'down'.)
 
  • #18
Looks like we're creeping into one of the problems that always happens between science and the english language. That is defining exactly what is mean't.

The question has now turned into what is colour?, and as shown above, the word colour is now being written in between quotation marks.

Although many creatures react to different parts of the EM spectrum, I would define colour as what our human eye reacts to, which is about 400-800nm.
 
  • #19
I believe everyone would, and the rest are kinds of light.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 35 ·
2
Replies
35
Views
5K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
Replies
11
Views
3K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
5K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 207 ·
7
Replies
207
Views
16K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K