Markownikoff's Rule: Why Does it Happen?

  • Thread starter Saoist
  • Start date
In summary, the conversation discusses the concept of Markonikov's rule and its origins as a predictive tool based on empirical evidence. It is then rationalized by considering the intermediates of a reaction mechanism and the stability of carbocations. An example of this is given with the addition of HCl to 1-Methyl-2-butene, where the more substituted carbon is favored due to its ability to handle a partial positive charge better. This phenomenon is known as the Markonikov's rule.
  • #1
Saoist
28
0
looked in books/googled for info about this...i know what it IS, but don't understand why it happens. anyone?
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
  • #2
Originally it was based on empirical evidence (it was just the product that you got from certain reactions) and was used as a predictive tool. It can be rationilized by thinking about the intermediates of a reaction mechanism. If a carbocation is formed then it will be more stable at the more substituted carbon and therefore a nucleophile would be more likely to attack at that position.
 
  • #3
Well, I ain't sure of this but consider a 1-Methyl-2-butene. When HCl adds across the double bond, Cl radical will attract the electrons of the C=C towards itself creating a partial +ve charge on the C atoms. This partial positive charge is handled better by a 3rd degree C atom than the 2nd degree C atom. Thus the -ve part of the addendum will go the the C with more substituents, which is the Markonikov's rule.
 

1. What is Markownikoff's Rule?

Markownikoff's Rule, also known as the Markownikoff's Principle or the Markownikoff's law, is a rule in organic chemistry that states that during the addition of a protic acid (H-X) to an asymmetric alkene, the hydrogen atom will add to the carbon atom that already has the greater number of hydrogen atoms bonded to it.

2. Why is Markownikoff's Rule important?

Markownikoff's Rule is important because it helps predict the major product in an addition reaction of an asymmetric alkene. It also helps understand the mechanism of the reaction and aids in the synthesis of desired products.

3. How does Markownikoff's Rule work?

Markownikoff's Rule works based on the stability of the intermediate carbocation formed during the addition reaction. The more substituted the carbocation is, the more stable it is and thus, the preferred product is the one that leads to the more substituted carbocation.

4. What is the origin of Markownikoff's Rule?

Markownikoff's Rule was proposed by Russian chemist Vladimir Markownikoff in 1870, based on his observations on the addition of hydrogen halides to unsymmetrical alkenes. It was later confirmed and explained by other scientists through further experiments and theoretical studies.

5. Are there any exceptions to Markownikoff's Rule?

Yes, there are some exceptions to Markownikoff's Rule, especially in cases where steric hindrance or electronic effects play a significant role. Some examples include reactions involving bulky reagents, cyclic alkenes, and conjugated systems. In these cases, the rule may be overridden by other factors and the minor product may be formed as the major product instead.

Similar threads

  • Chemistry
Replies
13
Views
3K
Replies
10
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
674
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • Programming and Computer Science
Replies
10
Views
2K
Replies
9
Views
1K
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
4
Views
792
Back
Top