Register to reply

Finding the distance to an Asteroid

by dimensionless
Tags: asteroid, distance
Share this thread:
Jan11-06, 10:22 AM
P: 464
When astronomers find an asteroid, how do they determine its distance from the sun? And for that matter, how do they determine its absolute velocity.
Phys.Org News Partner Astronomy news on
Witnessing the early growth of a giant
Orion rocks: Pebble-size particles may jump-start planet formation
Astronomers find evidence of water clouds in brown dwarf atmosphere
Jan11-06, 10:40 AM
DaveC426913's Avatar
P: 15,319
That's tricky one. They have to know its intrinsic brightness in order to know its distance. They guess, based on known bodies.

After more observation, they can determine its proper motion, which will help in determining its orbit, which will help in determining its position/distance.

All these factors work together to narrow down the range as they receive more data.

But, as one will note, in the study of planet 10 (I can't bring myself to call it Xena), they don't know its size very well at all, since they have no yardstick to measure its brightness. They also haven't had very long to determine its orbit accurately (which is > 250 years long).
Jan11-06, 11:08 AM
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
BobG's Avatar
P: 2,280
You take several observations.

Specifically, each observation has to record the time, elevation, azimuth, range, and range rate. The range and range rate could be found by bouncing a signal off of the object. The time it takes the signal to return tells you how far away the object is. The Doppler shift in frequency tells you how fast the object is approaching or departing. If you can't bounce a signal off the object, you have to estimate the range and range rate by other means (brightness, etc).

Since the object is unlikely to have moved very far in one night from the observer's perspective, it's hard to make 'several' observations very quickly and the accuracy of the range and range rate usually aren't very good on the first observations. This is why you periodically get a warning of an asteroid that may hit the Earth at some date in the future.

The initial observations are just to give other astronomer's the objects location. Eventually, you have enough observations to plot a trajectory through the sky. Having lots of observations and plotting them out is the only accurate way to determine the object's distance and velocity (just like calculating a lot of answers for various values of x eventually gives you a curve or line that defines an equation).

It's also why eventually the warning about the asteroid that may hit the Earth is discovered to be a false alarm. A wide swath of possible trajectories is eventually narrowed down to the object's actual trajectory.

Register to reply

Related Discussions
Finding the distance of 2 charges Introductory Physics Homework 0
Finding distance with velocity, Uk Introductory Physics Homework 2
Finding distance with a pivot Introductory Physics Homework 4
Finding closest distance Calculus & Beyond Homework 27
Having Trouble Finding the Distance Introductory Physics Homework 7