Tension on a string attached to model airplane

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around calculating the tension in a string attached to a model airplane that is moving in a circular path. Participants explore the relationship between the tension, the angle of the string, the mass of the airplane, and the radius of the circular motion. The conversation includes theoretical considerations and practical problem-solving approaches.

Discussion Character

  • Homework-related
  • Technical explanation
  • Mathematical reasoning
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant describes the problem of finding the tension in the string, noting the mass of the airplane and the radius of the circular path.
  • Another participant suggests that centripetal acceleration is necessary for the calculation and emphasizes the need for velocity.
  • A different participant points out the importance of considering the angle of the string and its components in both horizontal and vertical directions.
  • Some participants propose using vector addition to resolve the tension into its components, Tx and Ty.
  • There is a discussion about whether the model is simply hanging or actively flying, affecting the tension calculations.
  • One participant calculates the tension based on the weight of the model and the angle of the string, providing specific numerical examples.
  • Another participant raises a question about the relationship between the vertical component of tension and the weight of the model, leading to further clarification on equilibrium conditions.
  • Some participants express uncertainty about the need for velocity in determining tension, while others clarify that it is not necessary if the angle is known.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree on the need to consider the vertical and horizontal components of tension but disagree on the necessity of knowing the velocity for calculating tension. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the best approach to find the tension given the various parameters.

Contextual Notes

Limitations include the dependence on the angle of the string and the assumptions about the model's motion. Some calculations provided are based on hypothetical values, and the discussion includes varying interpretations of the problem setup.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be useful for students studying physics, particularly those working on problems involving circular motion, tension in strings, and force equilibrium.

lovin_physics05
Messages
13
Reaction score
0
this is a harder problem then i thought
well, do u knowthose model airplanes that are attached to somethinglike a cieling an the go around in a circle?
i have to find the tension in the string
umm
the mass of the airplane is 13kg
i dontknow the velocity
the radius of the circle it is goinin in is 2.0m
what else do i need to know or how do i solve theproblem, been workin on it for a hile but i can't getit
please help me out
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Since the plane is traveling in a circle, it has a centripetal acceleration. To caculate that acceleration, you need to the the speed and the radius. (You need more information.)

Once you find the acceleration, then you can apply F=ma to find out what the centripetal force must be. That force is supplied by the tension in the string (the horizontal component, if it is angled).

Hope this helps a bit.
 
well, ok that kindahelped. i do know howto do these centripetal force problems, usin Fnet=mv^2/r. where the tension is Fnet. but u can only do that if it is horizontal to the surface. my problem is thatit has a slope. so i set up an imaginary problem and pluged numbers in for that. butsay that i have all the numbers, can anyone give mean equation to use or what to do. usually u have to take that angle and make it into Fx and Fy, two lines. so i did that and then i used vector addition to find thehypotenuse, i think that's theranswer. ionly realized this thismorning, thanks for the help. can anyone tell meif I am right?
 
I assume you mean that the string is angled down.

Then you must find the components of the string tension (T) in the horizontal and vertical directions. In the vertical direction, there is equilibrium: The forces on the plane sum to zero. In the horizontal direction, Thorizontal is the centripetal force.
 
ok, so i don't know tension in the string, but i haveto make it into Tx and Ty, therefore i usethe equation Tcos(degree)= tx and Tsin(degree)= Ty. so to find tension in tx, i would use Fnet=mv^2/r

Tx=mv^2/r(cos(degree))
Ty=mv^2/r(sin(degree))

when i get those two
i use vector addition
r^2=Tx^2+Ty^2
want to plug in someimaginary numbers?
the thing is that he showed us the actual plane flying around, and wehave to find all the info our selves, butitsin school, so i have now way of figuring it out right now
 
Assuming the model is supported only by the string (it is not actually 'flying') then the vertical component of the tension in the string, must support the weight of the model.

If the model mass is 13kg, and gravitation acceleration is 9.81 m s ^-2, then the vertical component of the string tension is 13 * 9.81 Newtons.

If the angle of the string to the vertical is Δ then the total string tension is 13* 9.81 / cos(Δ)
 
ok, when i used my wn numbers, i set the mass to 13kg which would equal awieght of 130N

do u not need the velocityof the airplaeto determine thetension on the string since itisgoin around in a circle, i think i left that part out, that it is tied to the cieling by a string and it is movinaround in a cirle. say it takes 2.6s to completea rotation, where the radius is 3.0m
so velocity=2(3.14 pi)r/t
v=2(3.14)(3.0m)/2.6s
v=7.2m/s

so that's my velocity
 
length of string is 3.6m
 
If we know the angle of the string and the weight of the model, we don't need to know anything else. The string could be any length (this would affect the speed and the time taken for each circle - we could work it out).
 
  • #10
Originally posted by lovin_physics05
ok, so i don't know tension in the string, but i haveto make it into Tx and Ty, therefore i usethe equation Tcos(degree)= tx and Tsin(degree)= Ty.
Yes. (Assuming the angle is from the horizontal.) If you are given the angle, then finding the tension is easy. Just consider equilibrium in the y direction. For the y direction, what forces act on the plane? Those forces add to zero.
so to find tension in tx, i would use Fnet=mv^2/r
No, not Fnet. Only the x component of the tension is centripetal! Tx = m v2/r . But if you are given the angle, you can find the tension. (See above.) You will use this to solve for what you don't know, the speed.
Tx=mv^2/r(cos(degree))
Ty=mv^2/r(sin(degree))
No! See above.
 
  • #11
but i need to know the tension in the sring, notthe velocity
and yes, the anglegiven is fromthe horizon
wouldnt i find the tension of Tx and the tension of Ty and use vector addition to find T?
 
  • #12
Are you sure? A three metre radius circle with only a 3.6 metre length string? But you said 2 metre radius earlier?
 
  • #13
ok. with 3.6 metre radius string.

if circle is 2 metre radius, angle is 33.75 degrees, tension is 153.4 N
if circle is 3 metre radius, angle is 56.44 degrees, tension is 230.7 N

(the angle is between the string and the vertical)
 
  • #14
i may have said it incorrectly, but let me clarify
if the radius was 3.0m and the distance from the object to the ceiling(where it is attached) is 2.0m
then that forms a right triangle, where the length of out string is the hypotenuse
so therefore
c^2=a^2+b^2
c^2= 3.0m^2+2.0m^2
= 13m
c = 3.6m
that is the length of the string
wouldntu agree?
 
  • #15
Yes, and I think the answer I gave above is correct.
 
  • #16
Originally posted by lovin_physics05
but i need to know the tension in the sring, notthe velocity
and yes, the anglegiven is fromthe horizon
wouldnt i find the tension of Tx and the tension of Ty and use vector addition to find T?
You're overcomplicating the problem. If all you care about is the tension, then:

Ty = T sinθ = mg

Upward forces (string) must equal downward forces (weight). Solve for T. (This assumes, as ceptimus notes, that the plane isn't "flying".)
 
  • #17
my angle to the horizontal is 25 degrees, that's one that i made up just to get a sense of how to solve the real problem. now i already had that degree, so how do i use itto solve tension again?
sorry for all this
 
  • #18
Originally posted by Doc Al

Ty = T sinθ = mg
[/B]
did u mean Ty = T sinθ + mg ?
 
  • #19
for angle of string to the horizontal, divide by the sine of the angle.

Model weight = 13 kg. Tension if model is just hanging, not moving, = 13 * 9.81 = 127.5 Newtons.

If swinging in a circle with string at 25 degrees to the horizontal, divide 127.5 by sin(25) = 301.8 Newtons.

you can divide one figure by the other, if you want, to calculate the 'G' on the plane: this is just 1 / sin(25) which is 2.37 G
 
  • #20
Originally posted by lovin_physics05
did u mean Ty = T sinθ + mg ?
No. Ty = T sinθ

Equilibrium implies:
Ty - mg = 0, or...
Ty = mg, thus...
T sinθ = mg

θ, in these equations, is measured from the horizontal.
 
  • #21
ok
yes i think i understand now
so i wouldn't worry about Tx, just Ty?
i say this because u are dividin by sin
which is for vertical right?
 
  • #22
Originally posted by lovin_physics05
so i wouldn't worry about Tx, just Ty?
Yep. If all you care about is the tension, and you can figure out the angle, then you only need consider the vertical forces. (You really don't need to know anything about centripetal acceleration.:smile:)

Of course, if you now want to find the speed, you'll need to consider the horizontal forces. And you'll have to understand centripetal acceleration.
 
  • #23
great
thank u both so very very much
u guys really helped me out a lot
11th grade physics student from new jersey
by the way
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
6K
Replies
1
Views
4K
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 17 ·
Replies
17
Views
5K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
6K