Time slows as you speed up right, so ?

  • Context: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter Thread starter phillybaby
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Speed Time
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the concept of time dilation in relation to speed and the expansion of the universe. Participants explore the implications of relative motion on the perception of time, the age of galaxies, and the existence of a center in the universe.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

  • One participant questions the relationship between time dilation experienced by astronauts and the relative speeds of galaxies, suggesting that galaxies moving away from us might experience time differently.
  • Another participant confirms that time dilation is a measurable phenomenon and notes that observers in different inertial frames will perceive each other's clocks differently, but each will see their own clocks as normal.
  • Some participants argue against the existence of a center of the universe, stating that the Big Bang was an expansion of all space rather than an explosion from a central point.
  • One participant speculates on how different species might perceive time based on their relative speeds, using examples like pigeons and tortoises to illustrate the subjective experience of time.
  • Another participant presents a model of galaxies moving away from each other, suggesting that those moving faster experience time at a slower rate compared to those moving slower.
  • A later reply emphasizes that there is no universal concept of "fast," and reiterates that each observer in relative motion perceives the other's clock as running slowly.
  • One participant proposes a theoretical center of the universe based on the idea of everything moving away from everything else, suggesting that this center could represent a static point in time and space.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express multiple competing views regarding the nature of time dilation, the existence of a center in the universe, and the implications of relative motion on the perception of time. The discussion remains unresolved with no consensus reached.

Contextual Notes

Participants mention the age of the universe as 13.7 billion years, but there is uncertainty about how this age relates to different galaxies and their relative motion. The discussion includes various assumptions about the nature of time and space that are not fully explored or agreed upon.

phillybaby
Time slows as you speed up right, so... ?

Hi everyone, a new guy here with a question.:smile:

Having watched a few programs and learned a few things since i left school i have this question burning away in my little brain.[b(]
So I've found this forum, gone for the biggest section, and if I'm in the wrong section, mods, please move this.

Here goes.

If it has been proved that astronauts whilst wizzing about in orbit slow down a little, a second for that cosmonaut or something... so, that's only doing what 120k? what about the Earth in the Universe, i heard the figure in a program but forgot it.
This means since the big bang we've experienced time slower than something at the center of the Universe staying static, therefore our galaxy isn't as old as the center.. however the outer galaxies are going even faster ( because they are moving away from us ) so they must be going even slower, but as they were "born" first they might be the same age as us or younger!.. but then at the center things are running at the "true" time so could even be more evolved than us.

i've heard programs talking about time slowing down as you go faster, I've heard galaxies all moving away from us
i've heard we are going fast ourselves
but I've never heard of a link between all this that puts forwards these theories

Take it away guys. Thanks for listening to my mad ramblings.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
welcome!
(1) Time Dilation is proven (it's been directly measured)
(2) Yes, an observer in a different inertial reference frame than the Earth would measure Earth's clocks to be ticking at a slightly different rate than their own. But that observer and an Earth observer would see their own clocks proceeding "normally".
(3) There is no center of the universe. The Big Bang was an expansion of ALL space, not an outward explosion of stuff into the void.
(4) Galaxies appear to be moving by their own proper motion (e.g., gravitational interaction with other galaxies) and by the expansion of space (i.e., moving apart from each other but the creation of new intermediate space, not by a proper velocity of its own). The Time Dilation would result from the differences in proper motion through space.

Perhaps someone else can explain how the intergalactic timescales interplay (it's a bit confusing and I'm short on time :wink:), but they don't exceed the upper bound (age of the universe = 13.7 billion years).
 
1 yep :) that's where i started from.

2 makes you wonder if a species on another planet hardly moving/wizzing around at a stupid rate experiancing a different time rate actualy views it the same as us.
or for that matter, if the pigeon can see the world at a faster pace than us,( movies at 25 fps appear as a slow flicker to it ) does it's short life "feel" as long as our does, likewise for a tortoise going at such a slow rate, does it infact feel it's buzzing along quite happily and dosn't feel like it's had 100+ years. ( my twist on a theory on percived time depending on if your bored or having a good time )

3 a bomb goes off, of course there's a center, everything is moving away from everything else, so there has to be a center. at that point i would guess time is at it's true value as that point won't be moving.

4, yep, they are all moving away. let's imagine 3 cars, the rear is doing 20mph, the middle is moving away at 10mph, so it must be doing 30, the front one is also moving away at 10mph from the middle so it's doing 40mph.This is related to the center from above which is not moving.
if this is how the galaxys are moving, after all the material moving fastest in an explosion is at the outside, then the other galaxys must experience time at a slower rate than ourselves, the galaxys on the inside a faster time rate.
If i get what your saying each galaxy is moving at the same rate? the space inbetween them is just expanding. Could still have lots more time dialations tho, as we rotate on the earth, one sides faster than the other, as we orbit the sun, same thing, as Milkyway rotates, xbillion years we're going fast, next xbillion we're on the back stroke and going slower.

Finialy "age of the universe = 13.7 billion years"
thats in our time scale, like it or not we are moving, therefore we are slower in time, so how old is the universe really? not just our local bit of universe that we share the same time scale with ;)


heres another ditty, if your a light particle do you experience time at all?
 
Time does not slow down when you go fast. That is one of the most common misconceptions about relativity. There is no universal concept of "fast." It is properly said:

"When two observers are in relative motion, each will determine the other's clock is running slowly compared to their own."

Also, Phobos is correct -- there is no center of the universe. It's not like a bomb. Re-read what Phobos said.

- Warren
 
ok, our clock is running slower than galaxies moving faster than us, and vice versa.??

so the Universe is a ring shape? if everything is moving away from everything else it's expanding outwards. if you play back this in reverse everything will come together again in one place, ok no Universe, no time and space, but just after the BB there is a time and space, that position is center to me and probably static...ish

please understand I'm not some science graduate, i just have all these little theories running around in my head that make sense to me until someone gives my theories some new infomation that changes the settings my minds imagination can use. as far as I'm concerned there must be a theoretical center which is the place everything came from.

big thumbs up to the RI Chrimbo lectures btw :)
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 23 ·
Replies
23
Views
1K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
3K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
4K
  • · Replies 49 ·
2
Replies
49
Views
6K
  • · Replies 23 ·
Replies
23
Views
4K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
1K