Paradigm battles

by Andre
Tags: battles, paradigm
Andre is offline
Aug22-06, 12:50 PM
PF Gold
Andre's Avatar
P: 5,450
The earth science battlefields are as fierce as any other. One highly contested paradigm is the peopling of America. And quite unwillingly, a major feature in that battle is poor innocent Virginia Steen-McIntyre, who was so unfortunate to date volcanic ash layers that covered some paleo indian stone tools to an ago of some 260,000 years

That story is here and it took 15 years of ardent battling to get those results published in:

Steen-McIntyre, Virginia; Fryxell, Roald; Malde, Harold E (Jul 1981) Geologic evidence for age of deposits at Hueyatlaco archeological site, Valsequillo, Mexico . Quaternary Research, vol. 16, no.1, pp.1-15

As everything bound to get on the net eventually, this paper is now available too, at least the first ten pages:

But much more on her website here:

I love those little anomalies, challenging mainstream science and 260,000 old Clovis type flute points (normally 12-11,000 years old) is outrageous. However, looking at (studying) the pictures and reading the story, I'm not so sure anymore if there could be a simple down to earth explanation. That mud mixed with the tephra layer is suspicious Those tools may not be older than 260,000 years at all. They may in fact have any age.
Phys.Org News Partner Earth sciences news on
Bystander is offline
Aug22-06, 02:10 PM
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
PF Gold
P: 1,382
Quick look at the stratigraphy --- too many possible interpretations to call it an "anomaly" --- more along the lines of "Gee, it's the second half of the 20th century, and we're trained geologists, paleontologists, and can untangle any stratigraphic puzzle" vs. the hard reality of messy sedimentary processes.
Andre is offline
Aug23-06, 09:14 AM
PF Gold
Andre's Avatar
P: 5,450
Right. I was thinking of (recent) mud flows which do happen sometimes in hilly areas like that which could have mixed the tephra with mud as narrated, covering much younger strata.

But really, if true then it's again

The great tragedy of science, the slaying of a beautiful hypothesis with an ugly fact. Thomas Huxley

Register to reply

Related Discussions
About paradigm shifts General Discussion 17
Microsoft battles piracy with free software Computing & Technology 0
Paradigm of Brain General Discussion 9
Town Battles 'Demonic' Mystery Blazes General Discussion 54