Register to reply

Three mass pulley problem-Neat!

by nightflarer
Tags: mass, problemneat, pulley
Share this thread:
nightflarer
#1
Sep26-06, 05:49 PM
P: 2
Block 1 of mass m_1 is placed on block 2 of mass m_2 which is then placed on a table. A string connecting block 2 to a hanging mass M passes over a pulley attached to one end of the table. The mass and friction of the pulley are negligible. The coefficients of friction between blocks 1 and 2 and between block 2 and the tabletop are nonzero and are given in the following table (coefficient between blocks 1 and 2 for static friction is u_s1, for kinetic it's u_k1, for coefficient between block 2 and tabletop, static friction coefficient is u_s2, for kinetic it's u_k2.

Basically, you're supposed to find the acceleration of block 1 and 2, assuming M is large enough that as the hanging block descends, block 1 is slipping on block 2. There are some other questions too.

This was a test question, and I got it right for the most part. One of the questions was whether or not there existed a friction force f_1 exerted on block 1 by block 2, and if so, in what direction. I said there would be one of magnitude m_1*g*u_s1, and that's what a lot of my classmates thought since that's how the teacher had taught us in a problem we did a few weeks ago. However, now she says there is no friction force. What's up?

By the way, does anyone know where I can get access to old AP Physics Mechanic tests, especially the free responses? They'd be a good help for me for preparing for tests in the future. Thanks a lot.
Phys.Org News Partner Science news on Phys.org
Scientists develop 'electronic nose' for rapid detection of C. diff infection
Why plants in the office make us more productive
Tesla Motors dealing as states play factory poker
Doc Al
#2
Sep26-06, 07:04 PM
Mentor
Doc Al's Avatar
P: 41,477
Quote Quote by nightflarer
One of the questions was whether or not there existed a friction force f_1 exerted on block 1 by block 2, and if so, in what direction. I said there would be one of magnitude m_1*g*u_s1, and that's what a lot of my classmates thought since that's how the teacher had taught us in a problem we did a few weeks ago. However, now she says there is no friction force. What's up?
Assuming your description of the problem is accurate, of course there's a friction force between the two blocks. But since you earlier said that block 1 is slipping on block 2, why did you use the coefficient of static friction?
nightflarer
#3
Sep26-06, 08:42 PM
P: 2
Doc, the part I was referring to was a different section where M was small enough so that the blocks remain at rest when released. Sorry if that was unclear.

Doc Al
#4
Sep27-06, 07:25 AM
Mentor
Doc Al's Avatar
P: 41,477
Three mass pulley problem-Neat!

Big difference. If the blocks don't move there will be no friction force between them. (Just like if you rest a book on a horizontal surface: What's the friction force on it? None. If you try to push it and it resists, then there's a friction force involved.)


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Pulley/Torque problem where pulley has mass Introductory Physics Homework 4
Time problem involving Mass and a Pulley? Introductory Physics Homework 1
PLEASE HELP ME Pulley-Mass Problem Introductory Physics Homework 24
SHM with mass over pulley problem Introductory Physics Homework 4
Question about a 2 mass, multiple pulley problem. Introductory Physics Homework 8