Register to reply

Greenhouse Gas from a Volcano

by OSalcido
Tags: greenhouse, volcano
Share this thread:
OSalcido
#1
Mar30-07, 01:01 PM
P: 67
is it true that there are more greenhouse gasses released from a single Volcanic eruption than all of the gasses produced by man since the industrial revolution?

If so, shouldnt that silence the global-warming advocates?
Phys.Org News Partner Earth sciences news on Phys.org
Bystander
#2
Mar30-07, 01:39 PM
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
PF Gold
P: 1,384
No, hence, no.
OSalcido
#3
Mar30-07, 03:02 PM
P: 67
Any references would be appreciated

Bystander
#4
Mar30-07, 06:45 PM
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
PF Gold
P: 1,384
Greenhouse Gas from a Volcano

http://www-personal.umich.edu/~gwk/r...rt_Jan2006.pdf

This is the lower end of the range of estimates for annual volcanic emissions. You'll run into estimates three times greater.
billiards
#5
Mar31-07, 06:07 AM
P: 748
Probably not from a single eruption, but combined volcanoes do pump out more greenhouse gases than people. Umm, i can't really talk about global warming and atmosphere stuff cos it's not really my thing. But I belive that volcanoes pump out sulphate aerosoles, these things cool the earth down - I guess they increase the planet's albedo.
Skyhunter
#6
Mar31-07, 06:42 PM
P: 1,409
Quote Quote by OSalcido View Post
Any references would be appreciated
Volcanic emissions of CO2 are approximately 1% that of anthropogenic emissions.

http://www.bgs.ac.uk/programmes/land...tributions.pdf

That is another common denialist talking point that has been thoroughy debunked years ago.
Andre
#7
Apr1-07, 10:34 AM
PF Gold
Andre's Avatar
P: 5,459
Quote Quote by Skyhunter View Post
Volcanic emissions of CO2 are approximately 1% that of anthropogenic emissions.

http://www.bgs.ac.uk/programmes/land...tributions.pdf

That is another common denialist talking point that has been thoroughy debunked years ago.
And that's a strawman. There is no serious debate about the origine of the CO2. The volcangenetic CO2 is completely irrelevant. The essential problem with a strong GHG effect is the triple falsification of the positive feedback idea which is the key mechanism to catastrophic global warming.
inol
#8
Apr1-07, 02:30 PM
P: 7
The recent "Global Warming Swindle" documentary for example made the claim that volcanoes emit more co2 than man, and I have had plenty of arguments with people claiming that there is debate about the origin of the co2. Clearly it's not a strawman to say that it's a common argument used by skeptics.
ray b
#9
Apr24-07, 07:28 AM
P: 428
true lies and half truth

over total history I think the volcano's win
as they have been around alot longer then man
but billions or even millions of years ago old CO2
is long gone and plays no part in the current events

but over a given year no
maybe higher at peak in a real intence event
for a short period of time?
data sure is being SPUN
by both sides
BillJx
#10
Apr24-07, 05:28 PM
P: n/a
Quote Quote by ray b View Post
true lies and half truth

over total history I think the volcano's win
as they have been around alot longer then man
but billions or even millions of years ago old CO2
is long gone and plays no part in the current events

but over a given year no
maybe higher at peak in a real intence event
for a short period of time?
data sure is being SPUN
by both sides
Of course there will be false arguments from some individuals on both sides, but the wholesale falsification of data is overwhelmingly on one side. Answers to most "skeptic" arguments are well known and can be found here, among many other places.
http://gristmill.grist.org/skeptics

There's a much more wordy description of skeptic arguments here; it's a year old but doubt about AGW has only decreased since it was written. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn...301305_pf.html


Register to reply

Related Discussions
The greenhouse of Miskolczi Earth 17
Greenhouse Gas Equation Wrong Earth 8
How the Greenhouse Gas Effect works Earth 3
Greenhouse gases Chemistry 3
Greenhouse effect General Physics 2