Is AstroPhysics risky for career?


by SuperStringboy
Tags: astrophysics, career, risky
SuperStringboy
SuperStringboy is offline
#1
Nov2-07, 12:42 PM
P: 75
I deadly like to read and think the topics of astrophysics.I am an undgrad student of physics major. Is it really hard to make good career in astrophysics? are not jobs too much available ?
Phys.Org News Partner Science news on Phys.org
Going nuts? Turkey looks to pistachios to heat new eco-city
Space-tested fluid flow concept advances infectious disease diagnoses
SpaceX launches supplies to space station (Update)
Asphodel
Asphodel is offline
#2
Nov2-07, 04:14 PM
P: 451
The total number of jobs directly in astrophysics is decently small, although the number gets bigger depending on how you define the category. As such, it can be harder to get into than other career options. But if you love it, that's not going to stop you...you're doing a major in physics right now, and that's hardly easy, right?
wildman
wildman is offline
#3
Nov3-07, 03:03 AM
P: 252
From what I can see, a lot of people who study astrophysics end up working as engineers. It is kind of the safety blanket. These people usually end up as really really good engineers too.

SuperStringboy
SuperStringboy is offline
#4
Nov3-07, 10:46 AM
P: 75

Is AstroPhysics risky for career?


Quote Quote by wildman View Post
From what I can see, a lot of people who study astrophysics end up working as engineers. It is kind of the safety blanket. These people usually end up as really really good engineers too.
Hmm.....Interesting... So what can i do? I am really in confusion.
SuperStringboy
SuperStringboy is offline
#5
Nov3-07, 10:59 AM
P: 75
So will it be better to complete graduation in engineering and get the safety blanket.After that i should try to get phd on Astrophysics?
robphy
robphy is offline
#6
Nov3-07, 11:01 AM
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
PF Gold
robphy's Avatar
P: 4,108
Here's the current set of job ads from Physics Today:
http://careers.physicstoday.org/search/browse/
...which fluctuates as the year progresses. [Job ads will drop off the list as well.]
wildman
wildman is offline
#7
Nov3-07, 03:35 PM
P: 252
No no, don't study engineering. What I am saying is you don't need a degree in engineering to be an engineer. Go look at the IEEE Gold Medal winners. What degree do most have? Physics (including Astrophysics). Study what you like. If it is Astrophysics then study Astrophysics. One of our systems engineers has a physics degree, one of our quality engineers has a physics degree, we have several in optics with physics degrees and in algorthms... None of these people studied engineering one moment in school. Did it hurt their careers, no not at all.

Study your Astrophysics. It that doesn't work out, many companies will hire you as an engineer.
wildman
wildman is offline
#8
Nov3-07, 04:03 PM
P: 252
I need to give the warning that I know NOTHING about Astrophysics itself. Only that the company I work for hires people with physics degrees (including Geophysics and Astrophysics) as engineers. There doesn't seem to be any advantage to getting an engineering degree vs. a physics degree. I don't know if that is true in general but it is true where I work.

Maybe others can say if that is true in general....
ice109
ice109 is offline
#9
Nov3-07, 04:14 PM
P: 1,705
Quote Quote by robphy View Post
Here's the current set of job ads from Physics Today:
http://careers.physicstoday.org/search/browse/
...which fluctuates as the year progresses. [Job ads will drop off the list as well.]
unfortunately a lot of jobs on there are reposted in several sections. interesting to look at anyway.
SuperStringboy
SuperStringboy is offline
#10
Nov4-07, 06:23 AM
P: 75
Quote Quote by wildman View Post
No no, don't study engineering. What I am saying is you don't need a degree in engineering to be an engineer. Go look at the IEEE Gold Medal winners. What degree do most have? Physics (including Astrophysics). Study what you like. If it is Astrophysics then study Astrophysics. One of our systems engineers has a physics degree, one of our quality engineers has a physics degree, we have several in optics with physics degrees and in algorthms... None of these people studied engineering one moment in school. Did it hurt their careers, no not at all.

Study your Astrophysics. It that doesn't work out, many companies will hire you as an engineer.
Oh thanks i am feeling better after knowing this information.
SuperStringboy
SuperStringboy is offline
#11
Nov4-07, 06:27 AM
P: 75
Quote Quote by robphy View Post
Here's the current set of job ads from Physics Today:
http://careers.physicstoday.org/search/browse/
...which fluctuates as the year progresses. [Job ads will drop off the list as well.]
Hmm... astrophysics has more jobs than others...!!!
robphy
robphy is offline
#12
Nov4-07, 07:57 AM
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
PF Gold
robphy's Avatar
P: 4,108
Quote Quote by SuperStringboy View Post
Hmm... astrophysics has more jobs than others...!!!
While it looks good now, you should try to find out what the trends are in the near future (in time for your entry on the job scene). You might find out some info from http://aip.org/statistics/ . Visit this and the jobs-site above annually as you proceed in your education.
Locrian
Locrian is online now
#13
Nov4-07, 08:08 AM
P: 1,696
Quote Quote by wildman View Post
I need to give the warning that I know NOTHING about Astrophysics itself. Only that the company I work for hires people with physics degrees (including Geophysics and Astrophysics) as engineers.
That's unusual, in general. Most companies look for PE (or near PE) engineers to fill positions, largely for legal reasons. Certainly a fair number of physicists work as engineers, but the vast majority of engineering jobs are not open to them.
Locrian
Locrian is online now
#14
Nov4-07, 08:18 AM
P: 1,696
Quote Quote by SuperStringboy View Post
I deadly like to read and think the topics of astrophysics.I am an undgrad student of physics major. Is it really hard to make good career in astrophysics? are not jobs too much available ?
SuperStringboy,

In my opinion, astrophysics isn't risky so much as it is very slow. You'll have a job, the problem is that the good jobs are very hard to get.

You can expect to get your B.S. in physics, then spend on average 6 years in grad school, and then spend 4-10 years as a postdoc or other temporary position. These positions are often fun, and they give you a lot of freedom professionally, but on the other hand they are also temporary, and can make having any kind of stable life difficult. Many people in astrophysics feel like their careers really didn't begin until 35 or 40 years old.

You can really expect to work in a university the rest of your life. If you love the culture and the material, I think you can be very happy at this. You should also find out what typical salaries are for astrophysicists, and note that they are significantly lower than some other areas of physics. Obviously you aren't in this for money, but it isn't strange for people who say this to still be upset about getting getting paid what a middle school teacher does after 10 years of college education - and that is what you can expect in a postdoc.

In other words, the field is very rewarding for a select few. Make sure you're one of them.
Laura1013
Laura1013 is offline
#15
Nov4-07, 10:09 AM
P: 199
Quote Quote by Locrian View Post
You can really expect to work in a university the rest of your life.
While it's true that many astrophysics positions are within universities, you are not limited there. There are government jobs available, such as at NASA or ESA centers (as well as DOE and DOD, strangely enough), and there are non-university research institutes that also do work within astrophysics. Staff of observatories mainly maintain the facilities, but some also house astrophysicists who analyze the data.

Quote Quote by Locrian View Post
You should also find out what typical salaries are for astrophysicists, and note that they are significantly lower than some other areas of physics.
I disagree with this. From what I've seen, astrophysicists are paid very well, much higher than I was previously led to believe. Salary depends on a lot of factors, but I would say that astrophysics pays around the same as other physics branches (with some exceptions, such as medical physics, which is one of the highest paying).
wildman
wildman is offline
#16
Nov4-07, 10:14 AM
P: 252
Quote Quote by Locrian View Post
That's unusual, in general. Most companies look for PE (or near PE) engineers to fill positions, largely for legal reasons. Certainly a fair number of physicists work as engineers, but the vast majority of engineering jobs are not open to them.
Well, it depends on the type of engineer. For REAL engineers (meaning with a license) yes, that is correct. These are the people who build bridges or do public works. However in most of high tech (especially EE and software) real engineers (PEs) are quite rare. A company might keep one or two around for paper work and legal reasons but most of the "engineers" just have a technical degree, ie no legal standing. In software (the jobs where physics majors are often hired into), there are NO licenses in the US. At least that is my experience. No one I work with has a PE license.
SuperStringboy
SuperStringboy is offline
#17
Nov4-07, 10:29 AM
P: 75
Lot of time.........If i want to be rewarded and start a good career quickly i think i need to be the second hawking, Need big blow like hawking's singularity...Am i right?
How much its hard or take time to get a permanent job in Top class University as a teacher?
How much is the salary at the post doc period? Is it so low that even i can't buy a simple car?
I would really feel myself lucky if i could join NASA. But i want to research in theoretical Astrophysics.Can theoretical astrophysicists work at nasa? am again in danger? I have a very abstract idea. If i tell you you will tell me fool,mad,goat or something more. So not telling that.But if its true...oh i cant explain.(i asked a physicist about this idea. He told it can be true).Anyway I think to prove it i need new particle like neutralino (as far as i am understanding) which has penetrating power.So University job as teacher is the best for me.

I have taken few attempts to leave physics in my life.But its not leaving me. My life is not so large only completing first year in my university.Result will be published soon. I am scared if i fail ! Really wasted time by not reading text books properly and reading other books and thinking about ruuuubish ideas.

I thought if i can do well in astrophysics i will research on string theory later( i am a great fan of string theory and i am well known in my friends as string lover). But if astrophysics has this condition then what condition in career of string theory?Haahaha

Pray for me guys..hehe
Laura1013
Laura1013 is offline
#18
Nov4-07, 10:54 AM
P: 199
Quote Quote by SuperStringboy View Post
I would really feel myself lucky if i could join NASA. But i want to research in theoretical Astrophysics.Can theoretical astrophysicists work at nasa?
Yes, but as with theoretical astrophysics in general, the number of positions is very small.

I'm a little confused. You've completed one year at a university, is that correct? How do you know enough physics to form a new, publishable particle physics theory?


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Should i take this Calculus course or is it too risky? Academic Guidance 15
Astrophysics as an career Career Guidance 6
Astrophysics as a Career? Career Guidance 4